人生四个不能讲
9、人生四个不能讲
杨子 道藏研究 2016-01-06

大概我是一个内心不够坚强的人,多年来,总是感觉生命是在一直在雾霾中寻找什么东西,想想生活中的种种,虽不是富人,倒也所需不缺。那么追求幸福人生的道路上,我们到底最缺少什么呢?
我个人的观察体会以及这些年的学术研究发现,作为人类,与幸福关系最大的因素是----安全感。信仰之所以与幸福感正相关,就是因为各家信仰的教义都给能给予信徒心理上的慰籍。同时也侧面说明了唯物主义信仰的不可持续性。生而为人,物质是最基本的生存需求,没有物质,圣人也无法生存。但生命的意义,却远远不是生存,而是追求幸福。于是就有了唯心主义的信仰和追求。
于是我们便有了一个简单的逻辑:
信仰→幸福因子(心理安全感、希望感、永恒感、归属感、社交圈等)→幸福感提升(杨子,《信仰与幸福感的关系》)
在以上逻辑中,幸福因子有很多,但最重要的就是心理安全感。而在这一人群中,我是较为典型缺少安全感的那种。我原来以为自己是少数人中的一员。调查数据表明,我们绝大部分人都缺少安全感。
缺少安全感的人,情,是真的,心,是凉的。去年11月时我在公众号文章《老子说宠辱》中写到“人生四大靠不住”(春寒、秋暖、老健、君宠),当时觉得自己的心太冷了,这样的眼光看社会也太冷了。但后来从大家反馈的情况看,很多人认为就是他们生活的写照。这也正是这个社会缺少群体安全感的描实。

现实生活中,我们的人际情感,到底有多脆弱?以致于我们得整日小心翼翼地呵护着,一不小心就得罪了,一不小心就伤到了,一不小心就失去了。听说我们国家的维稳成本堪比军费,也不惊讶。维稳成本是整个社会的沟通成本,看看我们每个人的生活实际,维持单位里的平衡和发展,维持家庭的稳定和谐,维持我们的行为与内心良知的冲突平衡,这都应该是沟通成本的构成部分。几千年来,我们辛勤劳作,不曾侵略、不曾野蛮,却还是没能得应有的民族尊严。几千年来,我们勤奋工作,不曾欺骗、不曾背叛,却还没不能得到起码的安全感。我们为什么那么累?因为我们是一个情感含蓄的民族,我们的情感是如此的细腻,以至于一不小心就会伤到彼此。哪怕是我们最亲的人,最近的人。再亲再近,有些话还是不能讲,作为中国人,除了有“人生四大靠不住”,还有“四大不能讲”:
不跟父母讲累
不跟爱人讲理
不跟孩子讲恩
不跟领导讲功
简单说说。
(1) 不跟父母讲累。
生身父母,当你过了童言无忌的年龄段时,就开始要注意跟你父母的沟通了,特别成家立业后,“累”是不能跟父母讲的,西方文化认为讲了就是对父母的信任和尊重,中国传统文化则认为讲了就是不孝。为什么呢?“儿行千里母担忧”,孩子在外面做事,就算“不累”,父母也是担忧不止的,你再喊累,就给家庭增添了无限的负能量。父母不但帮不了你的帮,而且加剧了他们的担忧。除非你爸是李刚。在这一点上,几乎所有的中国人都能做到,而且做得非常好。不管多累,见了父母都报喜不报忧的强撑硬装着,实在瞒不住时,就找一个非常微妙的词来代替“累”,于是说“忙”,父母爱孩子是一种本能,孩子一说“忙”,一切问题全盖住了,父母不愿意拖累孩子,于是不耽误你“忙”,于是不多问了,因为中国有一个畸形逻辑就是----“忙,是成功的象征”,好象不忙的人,都是游手好闲,无所事事的没用的人。只有忙,才是存在的象征。那些忙得没时间看父母的人,忙的没时间关照家人的人,忙的没时间见朋友的人,其实不是真正的“忙”,而是一种内心的迷“茫”。当你到处烧香拜神时,其实忘记了
“堂前二老是活佛,无需灵山朝世尊”

那些对自己父母家人都不尽责的人,高谈阔论组织文化、社会责任,真是不知怎么修炼的。我们都在迷茫中寻找本已拥有的东西。

中国文字真是既有智慧又有内涵的,我们有一个词儿叫“忙得团团转”,很形象的形容了大忙人的生存状态----“团团转”,就是在原在踏步,把眼睛闭上几秒钟,脑子里浮想一下,做“原地踏步走”的场景,真是忍不住想哈哈大笑,两脚忙不停地在原地上下瞎折腾,就是没前进一步,累死了,也都是无用功。在中国古代,“忙”与“茫”是通假字,就是一个意思,心亡为忙,忙因迷茫。因为内心的迷失,才会着急地四处突围,今天见这个,明天约那个,酒肉朋友一桌桌,迎来送往一群群,前呼后拥高歌赞,幻觉已是巅峰人。这时的我们是看不到真实的结局的,因残酷的现实是:成功时都是鼓掌的,苦难时没有伸手的。正所谓:
“有茶有酒多兄弟,急难何曾见一人”。
可能很多职场得意的朋友觉我是悲观主义者,别着急,落难一次知道了。今年换工作,明年换工作,换了半辈子,还是小喽啰,忙了一年又一年,不见智慧升华,只伴岁月蹉跎。因为迷失了,所以没有了前进节奏和规划。一个客气的电话就可以随意打断你整块的时间。因为你对自己的时间没有价值观念。所谓应酬,实际是一种人际关系的维系投入。物质唯上的社会现实里,总让人容易忘记:真诚的心去待人,是有效的沟通方式,无需伴歌伴舞又陪醉。如果你有明确的人生目标和详细的规划,是不会把应酬当成主业的。热闹场里,往往是欢笑之后,最是寂寞。
知事少时烦恼少,识人多处时非多。

那些把事业建立在胃泡酒精的人,更是糊涂透顶。医生说那是在快乐地进行着自杀,我们每个人都同意,但依然我行我素。我较支持品酒养生的举止,但靠喝酒来开拓业务的,实在无法认同。可能与道家的“贵身”思想影响有关吧。一阵觥筹交错的繁华之后,冷静下来,蓦然明白:
相识满天下,知心能几人。
(2) 不跟爱人讲理。

爱讲理的人都是聪明的人,但同时也是缺少格局和智慧的人。家,是一个讲情的地方,不是说理的地方。理多情必寡。研究发现,女人爱讲理的指数与男人回家欲望成反比;男人爱讲理的指数与家庭幸福指数成反比。如果你一定要在家里把什么事都要说说明白,把理说透,非要分清谁是谁非,那么,最后你只剩下一个人,正确地孤独着。所以,我一直认为,人际关系分为三个层次:第一等人际,讲情;第二等人际:讲理;第三等人际:讲法。到了讲法的地步,都是撕破脸面的事了。关于这方面,我曾在《中国人为什么不讲逻辑不讲理》中有过较为详细的唠叨。应该是在公众号2015年10月份的文章,具体哪天的不记得了。有兴趣朋友可以自己翻查。我在那篇文章中提了不少歪理,都是阅读思考后的真实感受。
(3) 不跟孩子讲恩。
跟孩子要恩索情,也是我们这个民族的传统。所谓”养儿防老“也是是印证了这一点。我个人也经常跟女儿说:“宝贝加油啊,妈将来要什么要什么,都要靠你啦”,事实上,凭心讲,中国父母对孩子最是奉献无限,结果无求的典型了。我自己深有体会,虽然那样跟孩子说,但内心的目的有两个:一是给孩子奋斗的动力和压力;二是教育孩子要有家庭的责任感。如果孩子小从具有家庭责任意识,长大后会对他们自己及自己的家庭、对工作、对朋友、对社会都具有天然的责任感。没有责任的感的人,是无法取得别人的信赖的。但我这里所说的“不跟孩子讲恩”,指的不是这个意思。而是不在孩子跟前一直说自己为了孩子付出了多少辛苦和心血等等那些无休止的唠叨,那些给亲子关系带来负能量的东西,当下就让孩子下不了台,什么意思啊,父母这么累都是我害的?你让孩子怎么接你的话,这种沟通开局就注定了是失败的。父母爱孩子,是一种本能,不是一种恩情。就如吃喝拉撒一样的本能,你不能因此叫苦叫累,要知道,为孩子付出是一种本能,是一种责任,一种幸福。我平时很喜欢看《自然频道》,看到动物们为孩子让自己有孩子生存下来,都付出的艰辛比人类还多,但它们都很幸福和快乐。我曾看到一对企鹅看到别的夫妇辛苦孵卵很羡慕,它们没有自己的卵,就冒险去偷抢别的企鹅的卵。很多动物为了保护自己的幼崽不惜生命的事,处处可见。于不不免感慨,那些孩子不尽责任、对孩子不管不问的人,真的连动物都不如。哪怕我们有一千种理由,都无法开脱作为父母天然责任的事实。

既然疼爱孩子是一种本能,也是一种责任,于是对孩子就没有什么恩。索恩只会使孩子难堪,破裂亲子关系。如果你教育到位,孩子会尽一切可能的力量去孝敬你,用不着多说。这也是做父母需要修行的吧。
(4) 不跟领导讲功。
这个就不太想多唠叨了。一句话,跟领导讲功,死菜是迟早的事。越是有功的,越不能讲。无功的人讲功,是犯错;有功的人讲功,是犯罪。这是中国文化中畸形大观之一。在社会惩罚和报应上,遭一般人的嫉妒通常是有期;遭领导嫉妒是无期;功高盖主的,是死刑,而且是立即执行。永世不得翻身。只能等投胎转世的机会。有些投胎到别的公司去也没人要,因为没有领导喜欢比自己还有功的部下。生存危机感也是每一个物种和生命的本能。不信邪的可以试试。百试百灵。
年底了,要论功行奖,不跟领导讲功,更不能争功。举头三尺有神灵哦。
Four Things in Life That Must Not Be Said
46. Four Things in Life That Must Not Be Said
By Yang Zi, Daozang Research, 2016-01-06
I suppose I am someone whose inner heart is not strong enough. For years, I have always felt that life is like searching for something in a perpetual haze. Thinking over the various things in my life—though I am not wealthy, I have never lacked for what I need. So, on the road of pursuing a happy life, what exactly are we most short of?
From my own observation and experience, and from these years of academic research, I have found that for human beings the factor most closely related to happiness is—security. The reason faith correlates positively with a sense of happiness is that the doctrines of every faith can give believers psychological consolation. At the same time, it indirectly shows that materialist faith is unsustainable. Born as human beings, we find that material things are the most basic need of survival; without material things, even a sage cannot survive. But the meaning of life is far more than survival—it is the pursuit of happiness. Hence there arose idealist faith and idealist pursuit.
And so we have a simple logic:
Faith → happiness factors (psychological security, hope, a sense of eternity, a sense of belonging, one's social circle, etc.) → increased happiness (Yang Zi, "On the Relationship between Faith and Happiness")
In the logic above, there are many happiness factors, but the most important is psychological security. And among this crowd, I am the rather typical type who lacks a sense of security. I used to think I was one of a small minority. Survey data show that the great majority of us lack a sense of security.
People who lack security: their feelings are real, but their hearts are cold. Last November, in my WeChat official account essay "Laozi on Favor and Disgrace," I wrote of the "four great unreliables of life" (the cold of spring, the warmth of autumn, the health of the old, and a ruler's favor). At the time I felt my own heart was too cold, and that this way of looking at society was too cold as well. But judging from the feedback, many readers felt it was a portrait of their very lives. This is precisely a faithful portrayal of this society's lack of collective security.
In real life, just how fragile are our human affections? So fragile that we must tend them gingerly all day long: one careless move gives offense, one careless move wounds, one careless move loses. So I was not surprised to hear that our country's cost of maintaining stability is comparable to its military budget. The cost of stability is the communication cost of the whole society. Look at each of our actual lives: keeping the balance and development of the workplace, keeping the family stable and harmonious, keeping the balance between our conduct and our inner conscience—all of these should count as part of the communication cost. For thousands of years we have toiled diligently, never invading, never barbaric, yet we still have not won the national dignity we deserve. For thousands of years we have worked hard, never cheating, never betraying, yet we still cannot obtain even the most basic sense of security. Why are we so tired? Because we are a nation of reserved feelings; our emotions are so delicate that one careless move can hurt each other. Even our dearest ones, our nearest ones. However dear, however near, there are still things that must not be said. As Chinese, besides the "four great unreliables of life," we also have the "four must-not-says":
Don't tell your parents you are tired.
Don't reason with your beloved.
Don't talk of favors owed with your children.
Don't talk of merit with your leader.
A few simple words.
(1) Don't tell your parents you are tired.
Your own parents: once you are past the age when a child may say whatever comes into his head, you must begin to mind how you communicate with them. Especially after you have married and established your career, "tired" is something that must not be said to your parents. Western culture holds that saying it is trust and respect toward one's parents; traditional Chinese culture holds that saying it is unfilial. Why? "While the child travels a thousand li, the mother worries." When a child is out working, even if he is "not tired," the parents worry without end; if you cry tired as well, you add boundless negative energy to the family. Not only can your parents not be of any help to you, their worry is aggravated besides. Unless your father happens to be Li Gang. On this point, almost all Chinese can manage it, and manage it very well. However tired, when they see their parents they put on a strong front and report only good news and no bad; when it truly cannot be hidden, they find a very subtle word to stand in for "tired"—they say "busy." A parent's love for a child is instinct; the moment the child says "busy," every problem is covered over. Parents do not wish to be a burden on their children, so they do not hold up your "busy-ness," and so they ask no further—because China has a deformed logic which goes: "Busy is the symbol of success," as if everyone not busy were an idle, good-for-nothing loafer with nothing to do. Only being busy is proof that you exist. Those too busy to visit their parents, too busy to look after their family, too busy to see their friends, are not truly "busy"—it is a lostness within the heart. When you go everywhere burning incense and worshipping the gods, you have in fact forgotten—
"The two old ones before the hall are living Buddhas; there is no need to journey to Lingshan to pay homage to the World-Honored One."
Those who fail in their duty to their own parents and family, yet hold forth grandly about organizational culture and social responsibility—I truly do not know how they cultivate themselves. We are all searching, in our lostness, for what we already possess.
The Chinese language truly has both wisdom and depth. We have an expression, "busy spinning round and round," which vividly describes the existence of the greatly busy—"spinning round and round" means marching in place. Close your eyes for a few seconds and picture in your mind the scene of "marching in place"—you truly cannot help laughing out loud: the two feet bustle endlessly up and down on the same spot without advancing a single step; you can work yourself to death, and it is all wasted effort. In ancient China, mang, "busy," and mang, "lost," were interchangeable characters—one and the same meaning: when the heart dies, one is "busy"; busyness arises from lostness. It is because of inner lostness that one anxiously breaks out in all directions—meeting this person today, making a date with that one tomorrow; table after table of feasting friends, crowds greeted and sent off, hailed before and flattered behind—till in hallucination one is already a man at the summit. At such times we cannot see the true ending, for the cruel reality is: when you succeed, everyone applauds; when you suffer, no one lends a hand. As the saying goes:
"With tea and wine, brothers abound; when disaster strikes, not one is to be found."
Perhaps many friends whose careers are flourishing think me a pessimist. Don't rush—fall into misfortune once and you will know. Changing jobs this year, changing jobs next year, changing for half a lifetime and still a small underling; busy year after year, with no sublimation of wisdom, only years squandered away. Because you are lost, you have lost your forward rhythm and your plan. A single polite phone call can casually break up a whole block of your time, because you have no sense of the value of your own time. So-called social engagements are in fact an investment in maintaining interpersonal relations. In a social reality that puts material things above all, people easily forget that treating others with a sincere heart is an effective way of communicating, with no need for accompanying song and dance and drinking till drunk. If you have clear goals in life and a detailed plan, you will not make socializing your main business. In scenes of revelry, it is often after the laughter that the loneliest moment comes.
When you know few affairs, you have few troubles; where you know many people, there is much right and wrong.
Those who build their careers on a stomach steeped in alcohol are muddleheaded beyond all remedy. Doctors say that is happily carrying out suicide, and every one of us agrees—yet we still go our own way as before. I rather support the practice of sipping wine as a way of nourishing life, but winning business by drinking I simply cannot endorse. Perhaps this has something to do with the influence of the Daoist idea of "prizing the body." After a bout of dazzling cup-clinking splendor, when one calms down, one suddenly understands:
Acquaintances fill the world over; how many can know your heart?
(2) Don't reason with your beloved.
People who love to reason are all clever people, but at the same time people lacking breadth of vision and wisdom. The home is a place for feeling, not a place for reasoning. Where reason is abundant, feeling must be scarce. Research finds that a woman's index of loving to reason is inversely proportional to her man's desire to come home, and a man's index of loving to reason is inversely proportional to the family-happiness index. If you insist on making everything clear at home, on reasoning everything through, on determining exactly who is right and who is wrong, then in the end you will be left alone, solitary in your correctness. So I have always held that human relationships divide into three levels: first-rate relationships go by feeling; second-rate relationships go by reason; third-rate relationships go by law. By the time it comes to law, relations have already broken down openly. On this, I once did a fair amount of rambling in "Why the Chinese Are Neither Logical nor Reasonable." It should be an essay in this official account from October 2015; I don't remember the exact day. Interested friends can look it up themselves. In that essay I put forward quite a few twisted arguments—all of them genuine feelings after reading and reflection.
(3) Don't talk of favors owed with your children.
Demanding gratitude and pressing for affection from one's children is also a tradition of our nation. The saying "raise children to provide against old age" confirms exactly this point. I personally often say to my daughter: "Sweetheart, keep it up—whatever Mama wants in the future, it will all depend on you!" In all honesty, Chinese parents are the classic case of boundless devotion to their children with nothing asked in return. I know this from deep experience: though I say such things to my child, in my heart I have two aims—one is to give the child motivation and pressure to strive; the other is to teach the child to have a sense of responsibility toward the family. If a child has a sense of family responsibility from an early age, then when grown she will have a natural sense of responsibility toward herself and her own family, toward work, toward friends, and toward society. A person without a sense of responsibility cannot win the trust of others. But by "don't talk of favors owed with your children" I do not mean this. I mean not endlessly nagging before your children about how much hardship and heart's blood you have spent on them—that stuff which brings negative energy into the parent-child relationship, which on the spot makes the child unable to hold up their head—what does it mean, that Mom and Dad are this tired because of me? How is the child supposed to take up that thread of yours? A conversation that opens this way is doomed from the start. A parent's love for a child is an instinct, not a favor bestowed. An instinct just like eating, drinking, and all the rest; you cannot cry hardship and weariness over it. Know this: giving to your child is an instinct, a responsibility, a happiness. I love watching the Nature Channel, and I have seen animals, in order to let their young survive, put in even more hardship than human beings—yet they are all happy and joyful. I once saw a pair of penguins watching another couple labor over their eggs with great envy; having no egg of their own, they took the risk of stealing another penguins' egg. Everywhere one sees animals that do not spare their own lives to protect their young. One cannot help sighing that those who fail in their duty to their children, who ignore and neglect them, are truly worse than animals. Even if we had a thousand reasons, none could absolve the fact of a parent's natural responsibility.
Since loving your child is an instinct and a responsibility, the child therefore owes you no debt of gratitude for that love. Demanding gratitude only embarrasses the child and ruptures the parent-child relationship. If your upbringing is done right, the child will spare every possible effort to be filial to you—there is no need to say much. This too, I suppose, is part of the cultivation required of parents.
(4) Don't talk of merit with your leader.
This one I don't much feel like belaboring. In a word: talk of merit with your leader, and being done for is only a matter of time. The more merit you have, the less you may speak of it. For one without merit to claim merit is an error; for one with merit to claim merit is a crime. This is one of the grotesque spectacles of Chinese culture. In social punishment and retribution: incurring the envy of ordinary people usually earns a fixed term; incurring a leader's envy earns a life sentence; outshining the sovereign with one's merit earns the death penalty—and immediate execution at that, with no redemption ever, only the chance to be reincarnated. Some are reborn into other companies and still nobody wants them, because no leader likes a subordinate with more merit than his own. The sense of crisis for survival is likewise the instinct of every species and every life. Those who refuse to believe it can try. It works a hundred times out of a hundred.
The year's end is here, and merit will be weighed for rewards. Don't talk of merit with your leader, and don't fight for merit either. There are spirits three feet above your head.