胜得起,更需败得起
7、胜得起,更需败得起
原创 杨子 道藏研究 2021-01-09

百家讲坛的名师王力群教授有句话,说的颇有意思:
“小人物怕政府,大人物怕历史”。
意思是说:小人物怕权势,大人物怕史笔。
平日不看电视。除了道与其他传统文化古籍相关的读本,或者,与活150岁无关的事,我早已不关心了。
近几天出差。突然降温。长长的毛大衣和过膝皮靴也挡不了寒风,再用围巾连同口罩一裹裹,再裹裹,一圈两圈三四圈,整个人儿缠得跟木乃伊一样的,依然冻得嗦嗦抖。晚餐后,即回酒店。果然温暖如春。窝被窝里,经意不经意地打开了电视。本是练练听力而已,没想到,印象中,有着强大纠错机制的美国居然乱成了那样儿。川普的支持者们开始进攻国会。有人甚至为此丧了命。正所谓“物伤其类”,这些虽与我们无关,但同为人类,看到一个鲜活的生命突然终结,不免遗憾与伤感。死者也必是谁家母亲的心头肉吧。不愿直视画面。
一贯不喜政治,不关心政治,亦不谈论政治。更不愿意以写热点的方式吸引眼球,以博取无缘的关注。学术性公众号,本身就是要经得住枯燥,耐得住寂寞,眼前飘过繁华,关窗即是宁静的宇宙,或,丰富的内心世界,饱满的灵魂。哪怕那颗心是孤独的。
道,讲归一。佛,讲无二。一个意思。

但既然看到了,今儿,打算记录下内心一瞬间的想法。《圣经》说:
不要论断别人,以免被别人论断。(《马太福音》)

但真正的生活中,又哪一个人不去论断别人?又有谁不被别人论断呢?但愿这不是论断别人。至少,我本无心。确实不懂政治,请君不要理解为我妄谈时事。我对时事实无兴趣。只是出差偶尔看到的电视画面与我从书上读到的这个仅有200多年历史,但却有着旺盛生命力的国家形象,不大合拍。所以疑问。写作,即是思考,只是闪念即过,不思对错。
权力,是世界上最强大的毒品。只要有人尝过它的滋味,就立即上瘾,并终生会难忘。戒大麻易,戒权力难。
历史经验表明,权力的交接,多是残酷的,血腥的。古今中外皆如此。哪怕是家天下的江山(比如,唐太宗杀死兄弟、逼父退位;比如赵武灵王让位给儿子后觉得不自在,想再夺回权力,被他儿子关起来,活活饿死了,等等),更不要说公天下的体制了。
那些掌握国家权柄的人物,能在权力交接过渡时,保持国家的平稳和康健,不能不说,他们是非常有智慧的。任何一个国家领导人如果能做到如此,都应该给予和平奖。特别是那即将卸任的人。毕竟,交出权柄,即是结束政治生涯。对于政治人物来说,政治或许就是生命。
没有痛打落水狗的爱好,只是就事论事。而且个人而言,我比较川普的真性情,挺简单好玩的一位老人家。但他身为现任总统,为了一己原因,而让给予了自己无上荣耀和尊贵的国家遭受如此的伤害,其人智慧到底何在,无从知道。而让那些给予他无限支持的民众身处险境,甚至为了他送了命,他余生的灵魂是否安宁,不得而知。既然是川普是民主制度下选出来的国家总统,那么在他的治理下,美国应该更加民主和法制,民众的智慧和是非价值观应该更加大体趋同,为什么经他治理几年后就乱了套?无论谁是谁非,他的历史责任都不可推卸(不管他有多少理由)。这与一家公司治理不好,董事长、总经理不可推卸责任,一个家庭管理不好,家长不可推卸责任一样,无论有多少理由,没治理好就是没治理好。

如果他自信自己治理的好,就应该自信后续可以通过正规的法律程序去解决他认为的不公。如果他不相信自己治下的国家是公正的,那么他应该知通过闹腾是无用的。骚乱,伤害的只是自己的国家和民众。川普在位期间,对世界上不少国家造成过情感和经济上的伤害,他是为了他认为的本国利益,想想他的背景,我们或许可以理解,但如今对自己的国家造成伤害,真不知道他的脑子是有由什么组成的。难道他真的天真的以为历史就此止笔了吗?
只要人类存在,史笔便不会停止。历史就是历史,真相就是真相。不要说信息化的现代。就算在古代,也是如此。不禁想起中国历史上“崔杼弑其君”的历史事件:
崔武子见棠姜而美之,遂取之。---庄公通焉,骤如崔氏---乙亥,公问崔子,遂从姜氏,姜入于室,与崔子自侧户出。公拊楹而歌。侍人贾举止众从者而入,闭门。---公逾墙,又射之,中股,反队,遂弑之。
太史书曰:“崔杼弑其君。”崔子杀之。其弟嗣书而死者二人。其弟又书,乃舍之。南史氏闻太史尽死,执简以往。闻既书矣,乃还。(《左传·襄公二十五年》)
大意是:崔杼在丧礼上看到死者的老婆棠姜长得漂亮,就娶回家了。没想到他的国君齐庄公也看上了棠姜,就与她好上了(这是历史上绿帽子的由来)。

(注:男人喜欢女人的原因一般不外乎三个原因:1漂亮;2漂亮;3漂亮;历史事实说明,说女人心灵美可以让男人倾心的,全是谎言;说女人有才华而衷情的,更不靠谱。)
有一天,国君正在崔杼家和崔妻棠姜私会,催、崔杼联合朋友和家丁把国君给杀了。于是史官就写了史上著名的一句话:“崔杼弑其君”,这句话就是千古定罪,崔杼杀了国君,即有弑君之罪。崔杼当然不愿让自己背这个历史罪名,于是把史官杀了;史官的弟弟接哥哥的工作,接着写了同样的一句“崔杼弑其君”, 崔杼又把他给杀了。于是又来一了一个弟弟,同样写“崔杼弑其君”,这下子,崔杼实在下不了手了。只好算了。于是,事实就是事实,历史就是历史。
历史,是用生命写成的。古今中外皆如此。

值得一提的是,崔杼的愤怒和委屈是事实。绿帽子起杀心实可理解。任何一个有血性的男人可能都会如此。但弑君就是弑君。这是不可更改的事实。可能后人觉得他弑君可理解,但连杀史官就太过了。这也许就是后来的史笔中没有人替他报不平的原因吧。任何一个有点头脑的大人物,都明镜儿一样的清楚,史官,最是不可得罪的。
清朝的雍正皇帝,为了收拾那个风光了一辈子,当了所谓盛世之主的老爹康熙留下来的烂摊子,不得不直面可能的“身后骂名滚滚来”,但他却实在的告诉了儿子乾隆帝一句真理:“永远不要得罪读书人”,原因是,他们会写字,他们会写历史。
这种不得不讨好读书人的价值观,其实并不是中国传统历史文化的精髓,而是满清最明显的自卑心理。中国历史中,史官的风骨就是“写史,写实”,最早的史官就是那样的。“崔杼弑其君”这句话之所以有名,并不仅是弑君的事实,而是史官对写实的坚持,用生命的代价来捍卫史书的尊严。
那么,诸子百家,哪一家才是写史的呢?
道家者流,盖出于史官。历记成败、存亡、祸褔、古今之道。(《汉书 艺文志》)
《汉书》说道家是史官出身。这是事实。

这其实是刘歆给最早分类定位的。古代学术界都认为刘向父子(特别他的儿子刘歆)的分类非常正确,于是班固在《汉书》就这么抄录下了。后世的历史学者皆认同这一观点,包括近代的吕思勉先生。因为道家的鼻祖老子,就是周朝的史官,看到周王室腐败(居然公然索贿),就知道这个朝代要玩完了。于是他思索天地宇宙,总结祸福存亡、成败之道,留下《道德经》,西出函谷关,“不知其所终”(司马迁,《史记》)。

老子去哪里了,成了千古之迷。于是冯友兰先生,在给百家分类时,却借此发挥进行了一点微妙而深远的变动,他说:“道家者流,盖出于隐者;”,他这么说,有太深的用意了。看似是总结历史,有些道理,但却是把道家划到了正统的史学之外。这一招是比较狠的,他基于一些事实,但如果道家不写史,全由儒家写史,那么我们的史书就逊色多了,这倒不是儒士无才华,没文字功底(历史上儒家的饱学之士多如牛毛)而是因为不得已的本位主义无奈。普调显示,所有的通史中,哪部最好看?不用说,当然《史记》,鲁迅盛赞《史记》道:
史家之绝唱,无韵之《离骚》。
这一夸赞,一点都不过分。
司马氏写史,独步千古!
《史记》之后,再无《史记》。
难怪司马迁写完《史记》后,骄傲地说:“藏之名山,传之后世”,他觉得他的时代根本读不懂他的文章和思想,赶紧藏到山里去,留给后人读。这才是,文化自信。所以,司马氏不朽!
为什么呢?司马迁(包括他的父亲司马谈)为什么能写那么好的历史呢?因为道家往往置身政治之外,成天思考宇宙人生,有相对的思想自由、独立的观念不受束缚,阉了他,他也写真、写实。这就是史家的风骨,这是史书的尊严所在。读《史记》的人都知道,最有嚼头的是文章中、故事后的“太史公曰”,司马迁的议论,是他的价值观,才是影响我们传统思想的道家思想。只是很多人不深思这一点而已。

历史经验表明,阉割器官并不是最可怕的,阉割思想才是。
到了后代,多是儒家写史。读史的人都能感觉到,笔锋就少了很多风骨,多了些许媚骨。有些所谓的正史资料相互矛盾,为了一个统治者需要的历史形象糊灯笼一样补来裱去,靠谱度连野史都不如。《资治通鉴》算是了不起吧,但处处“臣光曰”说明了,那是司马光写给皇帝一个人儿看的,不是给我们老百姓看的。文中哪哪都透着一种苦口婆心的期待,以及不得已的臣本主义观点,看着看着就有画面感,眼前的司马光是跪着写的,恐怕也是跪着思考的,写好了也是跪着呈给皇帝的。
什么时候,我们这个民族不再跪着思考了,我们就真正的强大了。

南怀瑾先生说“几十年来始终认为,现在的世界就是春秋战国的放大,这个前途就可想而知”,而南师这一说话并不孤独,同样,季羡林先生也认为未来世界会走向统一。
我引用这两位国学大师的观点,是因为,我也相信世界早晚会走向统一。至于哪一个国家将统一世界,读读春秋战国,就大体知道结果。实在不知道,可以看看《过秦论》、《六国论》,可以猜着玩儿。
秦始皇统一中国,可不是他一代人的努力。更不是单单军事上的的原因。早在统一之前,秦国早就在文化方面准备好了,统一的文字、统一的度量衡、统一的法制等等,各国的人才都纷纷赶往秦国求职,这些都是前兆。
当年,项羽和刘邦争天下,张良为什么选择去辅佐刘邦?因为黄石公传给他一部书,书中指明了谁可以统一天下:
国将霸者士皆归,邦将亡者贤先避;
山将崩者下先隳,国将衰者民先弊。
(黄石公 《素书》)
历史上也曾出现过似乎世界大同的影子。英国曾是日不暮帝国,全球各处都有其殖民地,但英国终究没有统一全球的野心。网上有一句话说英国的特点,很逗:
英国只当搅屎棍,但不炸茅坑。
不知道谁给这么简明扼要的概括了一下英国。差点把人给笑死。

确实,欧洲前些年也尝试过统一,申根国家政策等等,欧元虽然还在使用,但英国又闹着要脱欧,这意味着欧洲的统一还远未作好准备。上世纪的日本也曾生过统一东南亚的野心,要成立“大东亚共荣圈”,但德性太差,最终被原子弹给轰趴下了。
胡扯到天边去了--

回到白宫事件。相对英国的政客,川普不但当了搅屎棍,临走还要炸茅坑。而他白宫智囊团的智商,也令人高度怀疑起来。这样的智囊团居然可以运营着全世界最风流的国家,不得不说这个机制中令人思考的某些优势。国家机器如果是健康的,放个臭虫在总统位置上也无所谓吧。记得多年前听说,太平洋一个小岛国,人口相当于咱们国家的一个乡镇,他们选总统的方式,就是在大广场上,脱了衣服称体重,谁最重,谁就是总统。多年过去,我一直很难忘,觉得这是历史上最公平的选举方式了。只要国家机器强大,总统的智商几何并不重要,只要选举方法公正,没有猫腻,社会就会太平。这似乎与老子所说的“无为而治”差不多的理念,老子说“太上,不知有之”,最好的君王,人们根本不知道他的存在,国家就运行得好好的。这才是好的国家机制,这才是当君王的境界。
不记得在哪里听说过一位学者的说法,大意是:劝美国的敌国千万不要去刺杀美国总统,因为杀掉他们的总统没意义,他们的体制立即会选出一位新的总统,而对他们的国家造不成什么伤害。
忽然想起去年一件事,当川普在推特上伤害我们的国家形象时,我当时也是揪心的难过,屈辱甚至愤怒,但却看到很多国内的爱国民众亲切的称呼他:川建国!还盛赞他是中国的卧底。当时没太明白,不关心政治的人,也没多想。现在,忽然有点似懂非懂的感觉了。
不得不说。网友确实高!

互联网,确实是个好东西。但确实也是个可怕的东西。可以成就一切,或许,也可能摧毁一切。
敬畏知识,敬畏历史,敬畏一切平凡和良善!
但愿我们每个人,都好好的活着。
活过病毒的变异升级,活过邪恶的权力游戏;
活过不公正的消失,活过这冰冷的寒冬。
等待春暖花开,等待正义的到来;
等待柔软的心灵,等待乾坤的清平;
等待可以拿掉口罩,人人可以自由的呼吸。

照例,两首道情送给你:
《古今一片天》
道隐不可见,经书藏万千;
身历三万劫,薪火代代传。
三洞有真义,四辅别有玄;
道心无分别,古今一片天。

《静坐》
我有紫霞志,踯躅在人间;
常颂清静经,无心万事闲。
高楼横琴坐,悠悠看青山;
长空走行云,日落明月还。
阴阳有定时,尘心古难全;
一静度万劫,观空云罩天。
YZ.2020.10.7

《亲》
遭难莫寻亲,寻亲必伤心;
休怪亲薄情,重情有几人?
YZ.2020.8.11
《情至深则无言》
道家入深山,逍遥不知年;
穿云行古道,坐听石上泉。
草低青牛卧,松高白鹤眠;
道路非天途,得悟心自全。
我有神仙友,相识在云端;
莫问道何在,至情是无言。
YZ.2020.10.7

《坐望》
坐望山海增离忧,此身常作不系舟;
不解冬日南飞雁,排空越云故乡愁。
梦思湖边茅草堂,不恋巍巍双子楼;
年年九月悲黄叶,纷纷落落心上秋。
YZ.2019.9.8

《神仙睡》
月下举杯花前醉,仙人赐我八千岁;
我问天人福何来,俯耳授我密中慧。
少思寡欲心清静,莫要无止贪富贵;
富贵场中多虚情,贫困才识真滋味。
不求显名情不辱,不登高台身不碎;
太阳缘何落西山,天道功成必身退。
休为嫁衣星夜奔,吟诗作赋折兰桂;
提笔只是随心意,不为圣人避名讳。
冰天寒冬孤心冷,静看庭前花含泪;
大雪纷纷封闲户,一片洁白示祥瑞。
至诚常为多情苦,多情不如无心肺;
十分美色何成就,三分营养七分睡。
虚空廖阔任仙游,闭目玄关云点缀;
还阳功,混元对,梦中只往龙华会。
One Must Be Able to Afford Victory, and Still More to Afford Defeat
44. One Must Be Able to Afford Victory, and Still More to Afford Defeat
Originally published by Yang Zi, Daozang Research, 2021-01-09
Professor Wang Liqun, the famous lecturer of the program "Lecture Room," has a saying that is rather interesting:
"Little people fear the government; big people fear history."
The meaning is: little people fear power; big people fear the historian's brush.
I do not usually watch television. I long ago lost interest in things beyond readings on the Dao and other traditional classics, or in anything unrelated to living to 150.
These past days I have been away on a business trip. The temperature suddenly dropped. A long fur coat and over-the-knee leather boots could not keep out the cold wind; wrapping the scarf together with the mask, wrapping again, one loop, two loops, three and four, the whole of me wound up like a mummy, and still shivering with cold. After dinner I went back to the hotel. Warm as spring indeed. Nestled under the covers, half by chance and half by intent, I turned on the television. It was only to practice my listening—yet what I saw, unexpectedly, was the America of my impressions, with its powerful self-correcting mechanisms, in such disorder. Trump's supporters were storming the Capitol; some had even lost their lives over it. As the saying goes, "creatures grieve for their kind": though this has nothing to do with us, as fellow human beings, seeing a vivid life suddenly end, one cannot help feeling regret and sorrow. The dead, too, must have been some mother's darling. I did not want to look straight at the pictures.
I have never liked politics, paid no attention to politics, nor spoken of politics. Still less do I wish to catch eyes by writing about hot topics, angling for the attention of strangers. A scholarly WeChat official account must in its very nature be able to withstand dullness and endure solitude: with the world's glitter drifting past before the eyes, one closes the window and it is a quiet universe—or a rich inner world, a full soul. Even if that soul is a lonely one.
The Dao speaks of returning to the One. The Buddha speaks of nonduality. One and the same meaning.
But having seen it, today I intend to set down the thoughts of a moment in my heart. The Bible says:
Judge not, lest you be judged. (The Gospel of Matthew)
But in real life, who does not judge others? And who is not judged by others? I hope this is not judging others; at the least, my heart had no such intent. I truly do not understand politics—please do not take this as my presuming to talk about current affairs. I really have no interest in current affairs. It is just that the television pictures I happened to see on my business trip did not quite fit the image of that country—only some two hundred years old yet so vigorously alive—which I had formed from books. Hence my questions. Writing is thinking: a flash of thought, passing in an instant, with no reckoning of right or wrong.
Power is the most potent narcotic in the world. Whoever has tasted it is instantly addicted, and the taste stays with him all his life. Quitting marijuana is easy; quitting power is hard.
Historical experience shows that transfers of power are mostly cruel and bloody—in China and abroad, in ancient times and modern. Even under dynasties ruled as a family's private realm (Emperor Taizong of Tang killed his brothers and forced his father from the throne; King Wuling of Zhao, having ceded the throne to his son, felt ill at ease and tried to seize power back, and his son shut him up and starved him to death; and so on), to say nothing of systems where all under heaven is held in common.
That those who hold the levers of state can keep a country steady and sound through a transition of power—say what one will, they are people of great wisdom. Any national leader who can do this should be given a peace prize—especially the one about to leave office. After all, to hand over the levers of power is to end one's political career. For a political figure, politics is perhaps life itself.
I have no taste for beating a drowning dog; I only speak of the matter itself. And personally, I rather like Trump's genuine temperament—a simple, amusing old man. But as the sitting president, for reasons of his own, to let the nation that had given him supreme honor and dignity suffer such harm—where in the world was his wisdom? And to leave the people who gave him boundless support in danger, some even dying for him—whether his soul will be at peace for the rest of his life, who can say. Since Trump was a president elected under a democratic system, then under his governance America ought to have become more democratic and more law-governed, and the people's wisdom and values of right and wrong ought to have converged more closely. Why, then, after a few years of his governance, did it all come apart? Whoever was right or wrong, his historical responsibility cannot be shirked (whatever reasons he may have). It is like a badly run company, where the chairman of the board and the general manager cannot shirk responsibility, or a badly run family, where the parents cannot shirk responsibility: whatever the reasons, not running it well is not running it well.
If he had confidence in his own governance, he should have had confidence that he could later remedy what he saw as injustice through proper legal channels. If he did not believe the country under his rule was just, then he ought to have known that raising a ruckus was useless. A riot wounds only one's own country and one's own people. During Trump's term in office, he inflicted emotional and economic harm on not a few countries of the world; he did it for what he took to be his own nation's interest, and thinking of his background we can perhaps understand—but to now inflict harm on his own country, I truly do not know what his brain is made of. Did he really, in his naivety, believe the historian's brush would stop writing at this point?
As long as humankind exists, the historian's brush will not stop. History is history, and truth is truth. Never mind the information age of today; even in ancient times it was so. I cannot help recalling the episode from Chinese history, "Cui Zhu slew his lord":
Cui Wuzi saw Tang Jiang and found her beautiful, and so took her. ---Duke Zhuang made her his mistress and went again and again to the Cui household. ---On the day yihai, the duke came to visit Cui, and followed Lady Jiang in; Jiang entered the inner chamber, and she and Cui went out by the side door. The duke tapped the pillar and sang. The attendant Jia Ju held back the other followers and entered, and shut the gate. ---The duke climbed the wall, and they shot at him, hitting his thigh, and he fell back, and so they killed him. / The Grand Historian wrote: "Cui Zhu slew his lord." Cui killed him. Two of the historian's brothers succeeded him in writing, and died. Another brother wrote it again, and Cui let him be. When the historian of the southern quarter heard that the Grand Historians had all died, he came holding his bamboo slips; hearing that it had already been written, he returned. (Zuozhuan, Duke Xiang, Year 25)
The gist: Cui Zhu, at a funeral, saw that the dead man's wife Tang Jiang was beautiful, and took her home as his wife. Who could have known that his own ruler, Duke Zhuang of Qi, had also taken a fancy to Tang Jiang and became her lover (this is the historical origin of being cuckolded (the "green cap")).
(Note: the reasons a man likes a woman generally come down to three: 1, she is beautiful; 2, she is beautiful; 3, she is beautiful. Historical fact shows that claims that a woman's beauty of soul can captivate a man are all lies, and claims that men are won over by a woman's talent are even less reliable.)
One day, while the ruler was at Cui Zhu's house for a tryst with Cui's wife Tang Jiang, Cui Zhu, joining with friends and household retainers, killed him. Thereupon the court historian wrote the famous line of the historical record: "Cui Zhu slew his lord"—a verdict fixed for all time: Cui Zhu had killed his ruler and bore the crime of regicide. Cui Zhu of course was unwilling to carry this historical charge, and so he killed the historian. The historian's younger brother took over his brother's post and wrote the same line: "Cui Zhu slew his lord." Cui Zhu killed him too. Then yet another brother came and likewise wrote "Cui Zhu slew his lord"—and this time Cui Zhu truly could not bring himself to do it again, and had to let it be. And so fact remained fact, and history remained history.
History is written with lives. So it has been in China and abroad, in ancient times and modern.
Worth mentioning is that Cui Zhu's anger and his sense of injury were real. That being cuckolded should kindle murderous intent is understandable enough—any man with red blood in him might have done the same. But regicide is regicide; that is a fact beyond altering. Later generations may find the regicide understandable, but killing the historians one after another was going too far. Perhaps that is why no later historian's brush spoke up for him. Any big man with a bit of brains knows it clear as a mirror: the historian is the very last person to offend.
Emperor Yongzheng of the Qing, in order to clean up the mess left by his father Kangxi—who had lived in glory all his life as the ruler of a so-called flourishing age—had no choice but to face the possibility that "after his death the curses would roll in like a flood." Yet he told his son, Emperor Qianlong, one plain truth: "Never offend the men of letters," for they can write, and they write history.
This value system of having no choice but to court the favor of the men of letters is in fact not the essence of China's traditional historical culture, but the most conspicuous mark of the Qing's inferiority complex. In Chinese history, the backbone of the court historian was precisely "write the history, write it true," and the earliest historians were exactly that. The line "Cui Zhu slew his lord" is famous not merely for the fact of regicide, but for the historians' insistence on writing what was true, defending the dignity of the historical record at the cost of their lives.
Then, of all the hundred schools of thought, which was the school that wrote history?
The school of the Daoists arose, it would seem, from the court historians, recording in succession the ways of success and failure, survival and perishing, fortune and misfortune, past and present. (Hanshu, "Yiwenzhi")
The Hanshu says the Daoist school sprang from the court historians. This is a fact.
It was in fact Liu Xin who first set this classification in place. The scholars of old all held the classification of Liu Xiang and his son (the son especially, Liu Xin) to be quite correct, and so Ban Gu copied it down in the Hanshu. Later historians have all accepted this view, including the modern scholar Mr. Lü Simian. For the founding father of the Daoists, Laozi, was precisely a court historian of the Zhou; seeing the corruption of the Zhou royal house (it actually demanded bribes openly), he knew the dynasty was finished. So he pondered heaven and earth and the cosmos, summed up the ways of fortune and misfortune, survival and perishing, success and failure, left behind the Daodejing, went west out through the Hangu Pass, and "no one knows where he ended" (Sima Qian, Shiji).
And where Laozi went remains a mystery for the ages. So Mr. Feng Youlan, when classifying the hundred schools, took the occasion to make a subtle yet far-reaching change, saying: "The school of the Daoists arose, it would seem, from the hermits." There was very deep intent in putting it that way. It looks like a summary of history with some sense in it, but it drew the Daoists outside orthodox historiography. That move was rather ruthless—and grounded in some facts—but if the Daoists did not write history and the Confucians alone wrote it all, our historical records would lose much of their luster. Not that Confucian scholars lack talent or literary skill (history has erudite Confucians by the ox-cartload), but their departmental self-interest could not be helped. A casual survey raises the question: of all the general histories, which reads best? Need one say—of course the Shiji. Lu Xun lavished praise on the Shiji:
The swan song of the historians; the Lisao without rhyme.
This praise is not the least bit excessive.
The writing of history by the Sima family stands alone through the ages!
After the Shiji, there has been no second Shiji.
No wonder that after finishing the Shiji, Sima Qian said with pride: "I will store it in a famous mountain and pass it to posterity." He felt his own age simply could not read his writing and his thought, so he quickly stored it away in the mountains, to be left for later readers. This is what cultural confidence means. And so the Sima family is immortal!
Why is that? Why could Sima Qian (his father Sima Tan included) write history so well? Because the Daoists generally stand outside politics, pondering the cosmos and human life all day, with relative freedom of thought and views unbound—castrate him, and he would still write what was real and true. This is the backbone of the historian, and herein lies the dignity of the historical record. Anyone who has read the Shiji knows that the most rewarding part is the "The Grand Historian says" within the pieces and after the stories—Sima Qian's commentary, his values, which are precisely the Daoist thought that has shaped our traditional thinking. It is only that few people think deeply on this.
Historical experience shows that castrating the body is not the most terrible thing; castrating the mind is.
In later ages, it was mostly Confucians who wrote history. Anyone who reads it can feel that the brush lost much of its backbone and gained a certain suppleness of flattery. Some of the so-called official histories contradict themselves, patched and pasted like a lantern being papered over to shape whatever historical image the ruler required; they are less reliable than the unofficial histories. The Zizhi Tongjian is remarkable, is it not—but on every page the words "Your servant Guang says" show that it was written by Sima Guang for the emperor alone to read, not for the likes of us common folk. Every page breathes an earnest, coaxing expectation, and the unavoidable viewpoint of the minister's station—read along and you begin to see it: the Sima Guang before your eyes wrote kneeling, no doubt thought kneeling, and when the writing was done presented it kneeling to the emperor.
The day this nation of ours no longer thinks on its knees will be the day we are truly strong.
Mr. Nan Huaijin said: "For decades I have held that today's world is simply the Spring and Autumn and Warring States enlarged; the prospects, then, can well be imagined." And Master Nan was not alone in saying this; likewise, Mr. Ji Xianlin believed the future world will move toward unification.
I cite the views of these two masters of our national learning because I too believe the world will sooner or later move toward unification. As for which country will unify the world—read the Spring and Autumn and Warring States periods and you will know the outcome in broad outline. If you truly cannot tell, you may look at the Guo Qin Lun and the Liu Guo Lun and amuse yourself with guesses.
The First Emperor of Qin's unification of China was by no means the effort of one generation, still less merely a matter of military causes. Long before the unification, the state of Qin had long been prepared in cultural terms—a unified script, unified weights and measures, a unified legal code, and so on—and talents from every state flocked to Qin to seek work. All these were the omens.
Back when Xiang Yu and Liu Bang fought for the empire, why did Zhang Liang choose to assist Liu Bang? Because Huangshi Gong had transmitted to him a book that made plain who could unify all under heaven:
When a state is about to become hegemon, the scholars all flock to it; when a state is about to perish, the worthy are first to flee;
When a mountain is about to collapse, its base crumbles first; when a state is about to decline, its people are first worn down.
(Huangshi Gong, Su Shu)
History has also seen shadows of what seemed like world unity. Britain was once the empire on which the sun never set, with colonies all over the globe, but Britain in the end never had the ambition to unify the world. There is a line on the internet about the English character—very funny:
Britain only plays the shit-stirring stick; it never blows up the latrine.
Whoever it was who summed up England so concisely—I nearly died laughing.
Indeed, Europe tried unification in recent years too—the Schengen policy and so on—and though the euro is still in use, Britain again kicked up a fuss about leaving the EU, which means European unification is far from ready. Japan last century also conceived the ambition of unifying Southeast Asia with its "Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere," but its conduct was too vile, and in the end it was flattened by the atomic bombs.
I have rambled clear off to the edge of the sky--
Back to the Capitol affair. Compared with British politicians, Trump did not merely play the shit-stirring stick; on his way out he meant to blow up the latrine as well. And the IQ of his White House brain trust also became highly questionable. That such a brain trust could run the most dashing nation in the world—say what you will, there are advantages in that mechanism worth pondering. If the machinery of state is sound, it should not matter much if you set a bedbug in the president's chair. I remember hearing, years ago, of a small island nation in the Pacific with a population the size of one of our rural towns, where the way they chose their president was this: on the great public square, everyone stripped and weighed himself, and whoever was heaviest became president. Many years have passed and I have never forgotten it; I have always thought it the fairest election method in history. As long as the machinery of the state is strong, the president's IQ hardly matters; as long as the election method is fair, with no tricks, society will be at peace. This seems close to what Laozi called "governing by non-action (wuwei)"; Laozi says "the Highest is the one of whom the people scarcely know he exists"—under the best of rulers, people barely know he is there, and the country runs along just fine. That is a good state mechanism, and that is the stature a ruler should have.
I forget where I once heard a scholar's argument, the gist of which was: one should advise America's enemies never to assassinate the American president, because killing their president is meaningless—their system will immediately elect a new one, and no real harm is done to the country.
Suddenly I recall something from last year. When Trump was hurting our country's image on Twitter, I too felt a wrenching sadness, humiliation, even anger; yet I saw a great many patriotic people at home affectionately calling him "Chuan Jianguo"—"Trump Builds China"—and even hailing him as China's undercover agent. At the time I did not quite get it; as one who pays no attention to politics, I gave it no more thought. Now, suddenly, I half-understand.
I must say it: the netizens are really something!
The internet is truly a good thing. But it is also truly a terrible thing. It can bring about anything—and perhaps it can also destroy everything.
Stand in awe of knowledge, in awe of history, in awe of all that is ordinary and good!
May every one of us live on, and live well.
Outlive the virus as it mutates and climbs; outlive the evil games of power;
Live to see injustice gone; live through this cold, cold winter.
Waiting for the spring warmth and the flowers; waiting for the arrival of justice;
Waiting for the softening of hearts; waiting for the clearing of heaven and earth;
Waiting for the day the masks come off, and everyone can breathe free.
As usual, two Daoqing chants for you:
"One Sky for All the Ages"
The Dao hides beyond sight, yet the scriptures hold ten thousand things;
This body passes through thirty thousand kalpas; the flame passes from hand to hand, age after age.
The Three Caverns hold true meaning; the Four Supplements have mysteries of their own;
The heart of the Dao draws no distinctions—one sky over all the ages.
"Quiet Sitting"
I hold the aspiration of purple mist, yet I pace back and forth in the world of men;
Constantly I recite the Qingjing Jing; with no scheming mind, the ten thousand things are at ease.
In the high tower I sit with my qin across my lap, idly watching the green hills;
Across the vast sky the traveling clouds move; the sun sets and the bright moon returns.
Yin and yang keep their appointed times; the dusty heart has never been whole since antiquity;
One stillness carries me through ten thousand kalpas; beholding emptiness, clouds veil the sky.
YZ.2020.10.7
"Kin"
In disaster, do not turn to kin; turning to kin only breaks the heart;
Blame not your kin for coldness—how many are ruled by feeling?
YZ.2020.8.11
"When Feeling Runs Deepest, No Words Serve"
The Daoist goes into the deep mountains, free and unfettered, losing count of years;
Through clouds he walks the ancient paths; sitting, he listens to the spring on the rocks.
In the low grass the blue ox lies; high in the pines the white crane sleeps;
The road afoot is not the road of heaven; with awakening, the heart is whole of itself.
I have immortal friends; we became acquainted above the clouds;
Ask not where the Dao abides: the deepest feeling has no words.
YZ.2020.10.7
"Sitting and Gazing"
Sitting, I gaze on mountains and seas, and parting sorrows grow; this body ever an unmoored boat;
I cannot fathom the geese flying south in winter, breaching the sky and clouds, heavy with longing for home.
In dreams I think of the thatched hall by the lake; I feel no love for the towering twin towers;
Year after year in the ninth month I grieve for the yellow leaves, falling and falling—an autumn upon the heart.
YZ.2019.9.8
"The Immortal's Sleep"
Under the moon I raise my cup, drunk before the flowers; an immortal grants me eight thousand years;
I ask the celestial whence blessing comes; he bends to my ear and imparts hidden wisdom.
Think little, desire little, keep the heart clear and still; never greedily chase wealth and rank without end;
In the theaters of wealth and rank, hollow feeling abounds; only in poverty does one know the true taste.
Seek no shining name and the heart suffers no insult; mount no high terrace and the body does not shatter;
Why does the sun set behind the western hills? The Dao of Heaven: when the work is done, the body withdraws.
Do not run all night sewing another's wedding dress; chant poems, compose fu, pluck the orchid and the cassia;
I take up the brush only as the heart moves me, not to spare the sages their names.
Ice-sky cold winter, a lonely heart grown cold; quietly I watch the flowers in the court, holding tears;
The great snow, falling fast, seals the idle door; a stretch of pure white shows auspicious blessing.
Utmost sincerity often suffers for its abundance of feeling; better to be carefree and untroubled than weighed down by feeling;
How is consummate beauty achieved? Three parts nourishment, seven parts sleep.
The void is vast and open, free for immortal roaming; eyes closed at the mysterious pass, clouds for adornment;
The arts of returning yang, the dialogue of Primal Unity—in dreams I go only to the assembly under the Dragon Flower Tree.