如果哲学迷了路
19、如果哲学迷了路
杨子 道藏研究 2015-10-22

J.R.Searle的《哲学的未来》是一篇前沿的文章。
哲学的未来,更是科学的未来。当哲学不再以兴趣、灵感、思辨、框架为主,转而以逻辑、目的、任务、脉络为主时,哲学就已退化为科学了。
曾经的科学家都先是哲学家,比如亚里士多德、张衡、牛顿、爱因斯坦等。现在都成了哲学家必先是科学家。
这一倒置的逻辑,看似可以快速得到实证研究成果。但事实是阻碍了哲学假设,从而限制了科学的高度。这是功利主义的结果。
现代哲学家都轻易登山了面前的土丘,忘记了古代的哲学家在珠穆朗玛峰苦等了几千年。
人类要去哪里?我们的哲学假设,决定了我们追求方向和证明的高度。
为功利哲学遗憾。
哲学的最大的价值不在于被科学证明,而在于对科学的引领和对精神的慰籍。哲学放下使命下山主动迎合科学,那山顶的宗教又该何去何从呢?
摘自杨子《清谈录》之
J.R.Searle 《哲学的未来》短评
If Philosophy Loses Its Way
35. If Philosophy Loses Its Way
By Yang Zi, Daozang Research, 2015-10-22
J.R. Searle's "The Future of Philosophy" is an article at the frontier.
The future of philosophy is even more the future of science. When philosophy no longer makes interest, inspiration, speculation, and framework its mainstay, but turns instead to logic, purpose, task, and context, philosophy has already degenerated into science.
Once, every scientist was first a philosopher—Aristotle, Zhang Heng, Newton, Einstein, and the like. Now it has become: every philosopher must first be a scientist.
This inverted logic looks as though it could quickly yield verified results. But in fact it obstructs philosophical hypotheses, and so limits the height of science. It is the result of utilitarianism.
Modern philosophers have all too easily climbed the small mound before them, forgetting that the philosophers of antiquity waited bitterly on Mount Everest for thousands of years.
Where is humanity going? Our philosophical hypotheses decide the direction of our pursuit and the height of our proofs.
A pity, this utilitarian philosophy.
Philosophy's greatest value lies not in being proved by science, but in leading science forward and consoling the spirit. If philosophy lays down its mission, comes down the mountain, and rushes of its own accord to meet science, what then becomes of religion at the summit?
Excerpted from Yang Zi's Qingtan Lu:
J.R. Searle, "The Future of Philosophy": A Brief Commentary