孔子为什么未能从政?
7、孔子为什么未能从政?
原创: 道藏研究 2019年4月6日

《心如止水》
心如止水神常明,历尽人间般般情;
阅罢千古兴衰史,山崩面前自无惊。
醒来方知名为苦,贵后深悟退是荣;
庆幸有缘识大道,三度劫难有神灵。
病三月。
病时尘情减,独处道心生。
近来的心情大体如上。
清明节,原是不打算写新的东西了,昨儿放假,整理过去的文稿,看到一篇过去写的,本想翻看一下直接编号入库算了。可能是清明节的原因,思想放纵,改着改着,远超了原文本意,也没了中心(语文老师读了一定要罚我站着听课)。如同一筐鸡蛋掉在地上了,无法收拾(哈哈)。又象是我们清明祭扫时在至亲墓前的诉说,只有真诚,没有头尾,也没有逻辑。絮絮叨叨,拉拉杂杂,都捆扎不起来了。尽管删减很多,但还是有点长。有空或有兴趣时慢慢看吧。
是以为文。此以为序。
为君之道,必须先存百姓。若扣损百姓惟奉其身,犹割股以啖腹,腹饱而身毙。---唐 李世民
随着社会的发展,为君之道,重点在建立一个对各方公平的体制。只有对各方公平,才能长保稳定太平。从全世界历史发展的事实来看,唯有强大的体制造就强大国家,才能长久。一时英雄豪杰造就的丰功伟绩,无论多么辉煌璀璨,在历史的长河中,都是烟花一样的短暂和不可持续。只有强大的体制,才可以造就持续的辉煌。所以,一个伟大的君王,不是让自己成为空前绝后的英雄,而是抓住时机,为他所掌权的社会建造一个可持续进步的机制。

无论我们愿意承认与否,美国的综合国力强大都是全世界公认的。这种强大,尽管有每一位个体的勤奋和努力,但更主要的,更得益于这个国家日益改善的体制。这是应该正面对待和平心而论的。就此而言,美国建国初期的总统,以及后世维护与加强这一体制的继任者们,当属这样的政治群体。还有,在全世界历史上,那些带头自我革命、改革旧体制、打破旧体制、建立新体制、维持新体制的勇敢群体,都是世人应该敬仰的伟人,不分国家、不分民族、不分性别、也不分信仰。
1945年,丘吉尔和斯大林有一段精彩对话,其中折射出的民生观,至今使人津津乐道。当时丘吉尔在一次大选中落选了,斯大林十分得意地说:
“丘吉尔,你打赢了仗,人民却罢免了你。看看我,谁敢罢免我。”
对此,丘吉尔不以为然地回应:
“我打仗就是保卫让人民有罢免我的权力。”
如果我们追求独立,一时不便与别人为盟,那也不一定是坏事。但对于优秀而强大的对手,潜心学习他的长处,要比批评他的弱点有用得多。就如一个穷人,不思如何去研究富人的经营之道,却花大量时间大骂人家“为富不仁”一样可悲。
前段时间,看到一篇文章,说我们批评西方的民主制度,就如太监批评别人有性生活一样。这话虽粗,但用到这个昏昏自大的群体身上,倒是有些道理,鲁迅说的“哀其不幸,怒其不争”,可能在这篇文章作者那里有更深的体会,所以才会打出这么一个解恨的比方来。

翻看中华历史,几乎每一个朝代的更迭都是相同的原因。吏制腐败、民不聊生,造成底层造反,从而帝王后浪推前浪,金銮殿上换新人。然后是,新朝开始,注重民生,怎么爱民如子、如何修养生息、如何轻徭薄赋等那一套,于是社会稳定、百姓安居乐业。再传下去,又慢慢的开始了后宫奢靡、权贵勾结、吏制腐败、民不聊生-----于是历史重演,几千年来,循环往复,不曾消停。
我们这个民族的知识分子,史笔从来都是有一种惯性,就是一直在大书特书,弘扬某一位官员的廉洁正气、两袖清风,气贯长虹的君子之风,以及诤诤傲骨、铁面无私、视死如归等等一类民族英雄。

民族英雄人物要不要歌颂和弘扬?当然要!必须要。因为这些人的精神是这个民族的精神代表,是民族文化的精华传承,也是人类精神文明的财富。
我想表达的是,我们的笔墨是不是可以用来剖析一下,为什么我们这个民族如此良善和勤奋,有这么多英雄豪杰,几千年来我们这个民族还在受欺负?我们的民众还在求温饱?为什么我们活得没有尊严感?我们这么高调推崇廉洁奉公,为什么历朝历代贪官杀不尽?以及,到底该怎么办,我们才能过上好日子?
这是我们应该反思的。我们需要英雄,但我们更需要改革不良因素的体制。等哪一天,我们的体制不再批量产生蛀虫时,也就不再那么如饥似渴的需要英雄来保护我们了。
孟子说:民为贵,社稷次之,君为轻。
这其实是个笑话。但两千多年来,我们却当成真理在传颂,真是荒唐。帝王这么说,是为了统治需要而不得不这么说。百姓这么说,是因为百姓一厢情愿地相信应该是这样,最好是这样。然而,事实上是这样吗?
“民为贵,君为轻”,翻翻史书看看,哪朝哪代“民贵”呢? 从史书中、从文献中,到处是“贱民”、“草民”的词汇,从未有“贵民”、“贱君”之说。相反,“贵为天子”、“贵为九卿”倒是充斥着我们的文化典籍。几千年来,年景无论丰歉,“公仆们”都是锦衣玉食,“主人们”都是食不果腹。孟子,是一位优秀的童话故事专家。我们这个民族,一直天真的生活在童话世界里几千年,不愿长大。

仔细品读所谓的圣贤书时,味道真的是苦的,苦到可以流泪。
圣人说话,叫圣人言。可是我们的文化基因中,还崇尚一种精神,叫“听其言,观其行”。

圣人也好,帝王也罢,嘴上说什么是一回事,实际做出来,才是他真实的德性。
举个例子,就拿“仁”政来说吧。我们历史上特别崇尚“仁”字,“仁”,似乎是我们的文化符号。君王都想成为仁君,知识分子哪怕杀身都想“成仁”,百姓盼望仁政如盼天露一样虔诚。就连我们这些凡人也一直想修一个仁慈的悲悯之心。那个厚脸皮的刘备一无所有,却把“仁义”发挥应用得淋漓尽致,他打着“仁义”的旗帜,终分得一份天下。
但何谓仁呢?有没有标准?
(此处略去一段)
有一个概念:对恶的仁慈,就是对善的欺凌。
于是儒家的仁就有了分别心,区别对待与否,是儒佛两家“仁”的最本质的区别。儒家的仁,是有分别心的,区别对待;佛家仁,是无差别的。
道,也是无差别的。
道家的庄子说:“天地与我并生,万物与我为一”,道家崇尚自然,万物平等,所以没什么分别心。但道家尚“德”不推“仁”,觉得“仁”比较虚伪,一个人“重道贵德”就已经很不错了。佛家的仁,主要表现是“慈悲”,最大的特色就是没有分别心,对谁都一样。在这方面,佛道无别。
最有分别心的,当数儒家。
儒家的分别心,不仅表现在对亲对友(易中天先生曾打过比方,说儒家的仁义是一圈一圈的,先老吾老,然后再人之老;先幼吾幼,再人之幼),而且还表现在行政执法上面。如果说儒家的典型代表是孔子,那么今天就说说孔圣人为什么未能如愿当官。

孔子一辈子梦想当官,虽然一直找不到工作,还顽强地、坚持不懈地周游列国,推销自己的施政理论。然而他为什么不能如愿地去执政治国平天下呢?为什么不能为当世所用呢?看了一些典籍中关于孔子从政的记载,才知道那个时代并没有埋没他。因为他确实不适合当官。我读书有限,但就个人读到的文献总结,孔子当官施政有三个特点:
(1)理论太高大上,本来只是解决百姓的点滴小事,他非要上升到三皇五帝的高度去玄而乎之,让人无法反驳,不可抗拒,但总感觉哪里不对劲。(此处略去N行)
(2)执法随意、判断主观。这个最要命。

孔子不是没当过官,他当过鲁国的代理宰相,只是很快就下岗了。在他当官的第七天,就开杀社会名流,而且是没有任何实证和司法程序。全是他个人主观判断。细读古籍,才知道,因“莫须有”罪名而丧命的第一人不是岳飞,而是少正卯。
孔子为鲁摄相,朝七日而诛少正卯。门人进问曰:“夫少正卯,鲁之闻人也,夫子为政而始诛之,得无失乎?”孔子曰:“居!吾语女其故。人有恶者五,而盗窃不与焉:一曰心达而险,二曰行辟而坚,三曰言伪而辩,四曰记丑而博,五曰顺非而泽。此五者有一於人,则不得免於君子之诛,而少正卯兼有之。故居处足以聚徒成群,言谈足以饰邪营众,强足以反是独立,此小人之桀雄也,不可不诛也。”----《荀子 宥坐》
这段话大意是:
孔子做鲁国的代理宰相,上朝听政才七天就杀了少正卯。他的学生进来问孔子说:“那少正卯,是鲁国的名人啊。先生当政而先把他杀了,该没有弄错吧?”
孔子说:“坐下!我告诉你其中的缘故。人有五种罪恶的行为,而盗窃不包括在里面:一是脑子精明而用心险恶,二是行为邪僻而又顽固,三是说话虚伪却很动听,四是记述丑恶的东西而十分广博,五是顺从错误而又加以润色。这五种罪恶,在一个人身上只要有一种,就不能免掉君子的杀戮,而少正卯却同时具有这五种罪恶。他居住下来就足够聚集门徒而成群结队,他的言谈足够用来掩饰邪恶而迷惑众人,他的刚强足够用来反对正确的东西而独立自主,这是小人中的豪杰,是不可不杀的。”

照孔子的标准,历史上不知道多少人都要被砍头。我估计连那些礼贤下士的孟尝君都可以上纲上线到这个层面去。孔圣人所宣扬的仁又在哪里呢?我们也无意在此埋汰古人,只是照孔子这种杀人模式,他要是当了官,杀人如麻可能是常态。用圣人的标准来要求常人,看谁不符合标准,就可以定位成小人,然后可以随便杀。杀人不需要取证、不需要司法程序,这是什么天理?这位满口仁义的圣人,想来让人不寒而栗。
但儒家学的实用之处,却也是世人无法抗拒的。“学而优则仕”一直是古代读书最高行动指南。正是:

《儒之用》
读书求高第,居官求名显;
得位为尊贵,尊贵不可言。
由于儒家学说是宗法社会的官方正统,所以,孔子被美化的神乎其神,任何人不能说孔子半个不字,不然就成为社会公敌。比如明末的思想家李贽,他12岁时对于孔子把种田人定位为“小人”,就极其不认可,开始写文章挖苦孔子。终其一生,他因抨击当时的统治思想---儒学而备受打压,他的学说被视为“异端”、“邪说”,他的思想被认为“敢倡乱道,惑世诬民”,晚年被捕入狱,实在不堪其辱,向理发师夺取理发刀,自已割断喉咙,悲壮的进入了历史。
不仅李贽,历史上不少思想家更是如此。仔细品读他们的作品,是一种精神上的升华,从而更觉得庙堂之上某些言辞的虚伪和浮浅。正是:
古来仁义名利重,偏是儒家回护多。
借助政治权势,对各家学说的打击和曲解,甚至妖魔化,是儒家对中国思想史上犯的最大的罪过,也是儒家不自信的表现。

作为统治者的御用学说,应该有义务和格局去维持思想生态多样性。
说来说去,这个民族的哲学史、思想库,需要更客观、公正、潜心整理、宣传,以及对民众进行无政治目的引导和普及。
然而,儒家愚民这一现象,直到现在都还在上演。
一统江山是件好事,但强制性地一统思想却是一个民族的悲哀。
中国人普遍认为,中国历史上最伟大的时期当数汉唐。核心的原因是这两个朝代国家统一、国力强盛。但其实在这种强大背后,道家思想为国教则是至关重要。汉初的“无为而治”才有了“文景之治”,为汉朝的强大奠定了坚实基础。汉武帝时虽是威风八面,但却是国力衰弱的开始。特别是董仲舒“罢黜百家,独尊儒术”之后,便开始走下坡路。一个国家与一个人一样,思想先滑坡,然后是命运衰落。就算汉武帝晚年下罪已诏,也未能挽回国运颓废的局势。唐朝时更不用说了,李氏干脆直接认老子为他们的祖先,把道教列为国教。然后唐朝的强大世不可敌。后武则天为统治需要,强力扶持佛教,于是道教和佛教成为主流。慢慢的儒学沦为三流学说。引起以韩愈为代表的知识分子拼死抵抗,由于道教是正统国教,又是本土宗教,于是韩愈瞄准了佛教这一外来宗教,猛力攻击,以《谏迎佛骨表》为标志性事件,发起了拯救儒家学说的文化运动。
(此处略去N行)

但从哲学、思想方面去研究的话,我觉得中国最丰富、饱满的时期,却是民族分裂、割据争雄的时期,特别是春秋战国和民国时期,其实是魏晋朝南北朝时期。在军阀割据争雄的时代,知识分子不属于哪一家政治力量独自管辖,所以思想、精神比较自由,于是才有了中国思想史上真正的的“百花齐放、百家争鸣”。唉,不说这个了。说来话太长。

那么,这个民族既然有这么多思想瑰宝,为什么今天很多人都不甚了解呢?
原因在于缺乏引导。这个民族在思想上似乎一直不喜欢去独自寻找食物,而是习惯了有人去喂养精神。
在法国读书时,曾与欧洲的一位教授谈及过各民族的特征,他问我们中国人的特征,我骄傲地说了很多,当然也曾婉转地表达,我们这个民族是一个被驯化了民族,因为这样说,似乎可以解释我们为什么被西方打得没脾气,也显得我们比较文明、比较有教养一些。今儿个,这是在中国写东西,自已人,关起门来说话。有些话我不想说,但不得不承认:奴性,是这个民族的一大特征。特别是满族入关之后,知识分子被减掉的是头发,被阉割的却是思想。高端知识分子跪着思考的情况,古来有之,很多电视剧中都有场景再现,每天上班,无论天大的事,都要等三叩九拜、山呼完毕后再汇报工作。皇上偶尔会恩典一句:“起来回话”---
我们这个时代的人,成长过程中经常听到一句话----“中国人民站起来了”。这句话我一直不甚理解,请问,我们啥时候倒下过?只有瘫子才对“站起来”一词那么敏感。其实一个国家被打得七零八落并不可怕,真正悲哀的是思想上的倒下,精神上被奴役。以上个世纪的一段历史来说,什么事情最让人热血沸腾?当属抗日战争!对于打日本鬼子,举国上下,那是比推翻满清还要激荡灵魂的事情。然而,我们历史影片和文学题材中,多是描述对日本的战争,无论是正面还是敌后,战场上打得血肉翻飞,也坚决不当亡国奴。“天下兴亡,匹夫有责”这句话对当时热血青年的激励,不亚于五四时期。说这句话的明末思想家顾炎武,一直埋没在历史尘埃中,他的思想却在他故去二百多年后大放异彩,在推翻满清及抗日战争中,这个民族开始重视思想对于民族生存的重要性。但近些年的影视题材与文学作品中,反应抗日战争的本子太多了,甚至有些编剧史乏词穷到胡编乱造,一些抗日神剧史学剧情的失真及荒唐程度远过神话小说。这样的编剧和制作组,挣多少钱咱管不了,只是想问一句:这么误导观众(特别是对史学尚未接触的孩子)良心可安?

其实我想表达的是,除了战争,我们还需要在思想领域的记录和宣传方面还需要加强重重的一笔,那就是这个民族在思想上的抗争、在文化上的坚持。当时民国政府决定要不惜一切代价把文脉保留下来。于是把清华、北大、南开三大高校一起南迁,而且一迁再迁。抗日战争爆发是1937年7月,联大迁往长沙是当年11月就开始了,1938年2月又迁往昆明。折腾与艰难可以想像。可见,在抗日战线上,不仅仅是枪弹和躯体的战争,也是文化和精神的抗争。那些在战争年代为了民族文化血脉延续而勤奋教学和学术研究的知识分子,也是如战斗英雄一样伟大。感人的例子很多。举个例子,哲学家金岳霖,曾在日机轰炸时抱着他的70万字的书稿跑到山上躲避,把书稿压在屁股底下,等轰炸结束,起身回学校了。后来想起后,书稿也就没了。这事真的让心灵震撼。(此处略去N行)
(上图为民国是最性情学者顾颉刚先生写的《古史辩》)
那个时期的知识分子,是有风骨和主见的,陈寅恪先生的思想精华可以概括那个时代的大致:
独立之精神!自由之思想!
---(此处略N行)
曾经一度,马列炙手可热,举国都在研究马列,精英们都骄傲地宣称自己是坚定的布尔什维克,而且一直保持先进性。相对,对于本民族的哲学,陌生得跟自己的穷亲戚一样,不想认,也羞于谈,更知之甚少。

启动对民族文化的兴趣,还是离不开政治人物的引导。近些年,有人揪出了毛泽东一句话“予于近人,独服曾文正”,好家伙,举国上下,洛阳纸贵,曾国藩的书火得了不得,大多数阅读此书的人并不是为了史学研究或提高文化修养,而是为了追风时尚或内心的不可明说的心思。尽管这无可厚非,但中国哲学史、思想史上大部分的精华,远远不为大众所知。
发现一个现象,在西方文化中,那些才华横溢的哲学大师们,在他们民族文化中,象天空的繁星一样被人们仰视和追求;而在我们当今社会的文化概念中,那些哲学大师,却如大海里的沙石一样,静静地沉在海底,不为人知。民众对自已民族精神的代表性人物甚至不如对一些三流名星绯闻的熟知,以至于会出现电影演员被推为国家精神象征的荒唐事件。
又扯远了。扯太远了。呵呵。
---(此处略N行)
在《荀子 宥坐》的同一章中,同样记录了孔子随意行使司法权的另一案例,篇幅限制,不再引述。
所以,有时候,倒是觉得西方的上帝之言更实在:
“不要看我做什么,要看我说什么!”

这才是一句实在话,因为说话容易,要做到真的太难了。说仁德,行无义,可能也是帝王之道吧。唐太宗李世民,那么勤政爱民,不也是手刃两个同胞亲兄弟的主儿么?但这并不影响他成为一位伟大的君王,杀亲归杀亲,无情归无情,人家把治理国家的主业做得空前绝后。这是公论。
心里话,我很不喜欢满口仁义道德的人。从中国历史上的诸多案例总结来看,此类人不是卫道士,就是伪君子。这类人动不动就先用一套理论占领道德的至高点,从而就可以上下其手,翻手为云,覆手为雨,无所不能。这种人很讨烦,但普通人又拿他没办法。
真小人对社会造成的危害,远远小于伪君子。伪君子常常拟态为圣人出现在社会上,出现在权力机构中,以“爱民”为由,行“害民”之实;伪君子也常拟态为“贵人”出现在我们的生命里,以“为你好”为由,行“践踏你”之实,这种伪友比敌人更可怕,更要命(详细可参看本公众号《伪友猛于虎》一文)。
提到伪君子,就容易激动。影响我修神仙心态,哈哈。算了,不写了。
文章太长了,一时难读完;
作者不怕累,唯恐读者嫌。
呵呵。
假期愉快!附两首平时胡诌的日记,给喜欢古体诗的你:

《病》
疼痛复疼痛,哀我卧病斋;
镜中颜色暗,窗外云雨乖。
朦胧双亲至,恍惚故人来;
甘露顿清神,观音下莲台。
笔墨泪痕干,纸砚满尘埃;
久病捱岁月,彩霞复满怀。
终得衣带宽,翩翩好身材;
此身承沉疴,此心多精彩。
YZ.2019.3.12
生病 ,一点也不好玩儿。痛死了痛死了。痛到发昏,犯迷糊。恍惚间,亲朋好友都在眼前,就连各路神仙、菩萨也都来了,忽然有点理解老人们讲的“过阴”的可信性。清醒后发现不是那么回事。说明离神仙还有距离,还有距离。

《月升东海外》
月升东海外,日落西山头;
弦间为离恨,笔下是春愁。
念彼修行者,半生把道求;
不为一已私,只为苍生谋。
Why Did Confucius Never Get to Govern?
7. Why Did Confucius Never Get to Govern?
Originally published by Daozang Yanjiu, 2019-04-06
"A Heart Like Still Water"
A heart like still water, the spirit ever bright, having lived through every feeling the human world holds;
having read the whole rise and fall of a thousand ages, one stands unshaken before a mountain's collapse.
Waking, one finally knows that name means suffering; ennobled, one learns deep down that withdrawal is glory;
thankful to have met the great Dao by fate--through three trials and tribulations, the gods were there.
Ill for three months.
In illness the worldly feelings lessen; in solitude, the Dao-heart is born.
My state of mind of late has been, on the whole, as above.
At Qingming I had originally not planned to write anything new. Yesterday was a holiday, and while sorting through old drafts I came upon a piece written long ago. I meant only to glance over it and file it away under its number. Perhaps because of Qingming, my thoughts ran loose; revising and revising, I drifted far past the original intent, and lost the center too (my language teacher, reading this, would surely make me stand through the lesson). It was like a basket of eggs dropped on the floor, impossible to gather up (ha ha). Or like what we say at Qingming before the graves of our dearest--only sincerity, no head, no tail, no logic. Rambling and rambling, scattered and jumbled, impossible to bundle back together. Much as I have cut, it is still a bit long. Read it slowly, when you have time or interest.
So this essay. Let this stand as its preface.
The way of ruling for a ruler must begin with keeping the people alive. To pare down the people merely to serve one's own body is like cutting the flesh of one's own thigh to feed one's belly: the belly is filled, and the body dies. -- Li Shimin of the Tang
As society develops, the way of ruling for a ruler centers on building a system that is fair to all parties. Only when it is fair to all parties can stability and peace be long assured. Judging from the facts of world history, only a strong system makes a strong state, and only that can last. The mighty deeds achieved by the heroes and champions of a moment, however brilliant and dazzling, are in the long river of history as brief and unsustainable as fireworks. Only a strong system can produce enduring glory. So a great ruler is not one who makes himself a hero without precedent or successor, but one who seizes the moment and builds for the society under his power a mechanism of sustainable progress.
Whether we are willing to admit it or not, the comprehensive national power of the United States is recognized by the whole world. Behind that power, besides the diligence and effort of every individual, lies above all this country's ever-improving system. This is something to face squarely and weigh with a calm mind. In this respect, the early presidents of the United States, and the successors who maintained and strengthened this system, belong to just such a political group. And in the history of the whole world, those brave groups who led the way in self-revolution, reformed the old systems, broke the old systems, built new ones, and sustained the new ones--all are great people the world should look up to, regardless of country, nation, gender, or creed.
In 1945 Churchill and Stalin had a brilliant exchange, and the view of the people's welfare it revealed is still relished today. Churchill had just lost a general election, and Stalin said, mightily pleased:
"Churchill, you won the war, and the people dismissed you. Look at me: who would dare dismiss me."
To this Churchill replied, unimpressed:
"I fought the war precisely to defend the people's power to dismiss me."
If we pursue independence and for a time find it inconvenient to ally with others, that need not be a bad thing. But toward an excellent and powerful opponent, quietly studying his strengths is far more useful than criticizing his weaknesses. It is as wretched as a poor man who, instead of studying how the rich run their affairs, spends great gobs of time loudly cursing them for "getting rich without a conscience."
A while back I saw an article saying that our criticizing the Western democratic system is like a eunuch criticizing other people for having a sex life. The words are coarse, but applied to this muddled, self-satisfied crowd they make a certain sense. Lu Xun's "mourning their misfortune, raging at their spinelessness" may have struck that article's author with special force, which is why he came up with so satisfying an analogy.
Leaf through Chinese history: nearly every change of dynasty came from the same causes. Rotten administration, the people unable to live, revolt from the bottom--and so ruler after ruler wave upon wave, new faces on the golden throne. Then the new dynasty begins, attentive to the people's livelihood: how to love the people as one's children, how to let them rest and recover, how to lighten taxes and corvee, that whole repertoire--and so society stabilizes and the people settle happily into their work. Pass it on a while, and slowly it begins again: extravagance in the rear palace, the powerful in league, rotten administration, the people unable to live-----and so history replays itself, round after round, for thousands of years, never once resting.
The historians of our nation have always had an inertia of the brush: endlessly writing up and celebrating some official's honesty and uprightness, incorruptibility, with nothing but a breeze in both sleeves, the gentleman's air spanning the sky like a rainbow, and the unbending bones, iron faces, and scorn for death of that class of national hero.
Should national heroes be sung and celebrated? Of course! They must be. For the spirit of these people is the representative spirit of this nation, the distilled inheritance of its culture, and part of the wealth of human civilization.
What I want to say is: might our ink also be spent dissecting why, when this nation of ours is so good and so diligent and has produced so many heroes and champions, we have been bullied for these thousands of years? Our people are still seeking food and warmth? Why do we live without a sense of dignity? We laud integrity and devotion to public duty to the skies--why, then, could the corrupt officials never be killed off, dynasty after dynasty? And what, in the end, must be done for us to live good lives?
This is what we should reflect on. We need heroes--but still more we need a system that reforms the harmful elements. The day our system no longer mass-produces corrupt parasites will be the day we no longer thirst so desperately for heroes to protect us.
Mencius said: the people are the most precious; the altars of state come next; the ruler counts for least.
This is in fact a joke. But for more than two thousand years we have passed it around as truth--truly absurd. The emperors said it because the needs of ruling forced the words out of them. The common people said it because they fondly, one-sidedly believed that it ought to be so, and that it would be best if it were so. But in fact, is it so?
"The people are precious, the ruler is light"--turn the pages of the histories and look: in which dynasty, in which age, were "the people precious"? Through the histories and the documents run the words "mean people" and "grass people," never "precious people" or "mean ruler." On the contrary, "precious as the Son of Heaven" and "precious as one of the Nine Ministers" fill our cultural canon. For thousands of years, feast or famine, the "public servants" have dressed in brocade and eaten like kings, while the "masters" have gone without enough food in their bellies. Mencius was an outstanding writer of fairy tales. Our nation has lived innocently in a fairy-tale world for thousands of years, unwilling to grow up.
Read the so-called books of the sages closely enough, and the taste is truly bitter--bitter enough to bring tears.
When a sage speaks, it is called the sage's word. Yet in our cultural genes we also honor a spirit called "listen to his words and watch his deeds."
Sage or emperor, what a man says with his mouth is one thing; what he actually does is his real de. To give an example, take "ren" government. Our history especially reveres the word "ren": "ren" seems to be our cultural symbol. Rulers all wished to become humane rulers; scholars would "achieve ren" even at the cost of their lives; the people hoped for humane rule as devoutly as for heavenly dew. Even we ordinary folk have always wanted to cultivate a humane and compassionate heart. That thick-skinned Liu Bei had nothing at all, yet he played "ren and yi" to the fullest; under the banner of "ren and yi" he carved out in the end a share of the realm.
But what is ren? Is there a standard?
(A passage is omitted here)
There is one notion: mercy toward evil is the bullying of good.
So the Confucian ren came to carry a discriminating mind; whether one discriminates or not is the most essential difference between Confucian and Buddhist "ren." The Confucian ren has a discriminating mind and treats people differently; the Buddhist ren is without distinction.
The Dao, too, is without distinction.
Zhuangzi of the Daoist school said: "Heaven and earth were born together with me, and the ten thousand things and I are one." The Daoist school honors nature and the equality of all things, so it has no discriminating mind. But the Daoists esteem "de" and do not push "ren," finding "ren" rather false; for a person to "revere the Dao and prize de" is already quite good. The Buddhist ren shows itself chiefly as "compassion," and its greatest feature is that it has no mind of partiality--it is the same toward everyone. In this, Buddhism and Daoism differ not at all.
The school with the most discriminating mind must be the Confucian.
The Confucian discriminating mind shows not only toward kin and friends (Mr. Yi Zhongtian once gave the analogy that Confucian humaneness and righteousness is ring upon ring: first one's own elders, then the elders of others; first one's own young, then the young of others), but also in administration and the enforcement of law. If the typical representative of the Confucians is Confucius, then today let us speak of why the sage Confucius never got the official post he wished for.
Confucius dreamed of office all his life. Though he never found a job, he stubbornly, untiringly made his rounds of the states, marketing his theory of government. Why, then, could he never govern as he wished, never bring order to the realm? Why was he of no use to his own age? Having read some records in the classics of Confucius in office, I learned that the age did not bury him. The truth is that he simply was not suited to be an official. My reading is limited, but from the documents I have read, Confucius as an official had three characteristics:
(1) His theory was too lofty. What was only a matter of solving the people's small everyday affairs he insisted on raising to the height of the Three Sovereigns and Five Emperors and shrouding in mystery, so that one could neither refute nor resist it--yet something always felt off. (N lines omitted here)
(2) Arbitrary enforcement of law and subjective judgment. This is the deadliest.
It is not that Confucius never held office; he was acting prime minister of Lu, and was laid off very quickly. On the seventh day in office he put to death a social celebrity, and that with no evidence and no judicial process whatsoever--all of it his own subjective judgment. Read the old texts closely and you learn: the first man to die on "trumped-up" charges was not Yue Fei, but Shaozheng Mao.
Confucius, as acting minister of Lu, after seven days at court put Shaozheng Mao to death. A disciple came in and asked: "That Shaozheng Mao was a man of note in Lu. You take up the government and the first thing you do is put him to death--could there not be some mistake?" Confucius said: "Sit! I will tell you the reason. There are five evil things in a man, and theft does not count among them: first, a mind that is perceptive but sinister; second, conduct that is perverse and stubborn; third, speech that is false yet plausible; fourth, a memory for ugly things, broad in its reach; fifth, following what is wrong and glossing it over. If a man has but one of these five, he cannot escape the gentleman's execution--and Shaozheng Mao had all five. Where he lived, he could gather followers into a crowd; his talk could deck out error and beguile the multitude; his force was enough to set himself up in defiance of what is right. This is a formidable figure among petty men; he could not be spared." -- Xunzi, "Youzuo"
The gist of this passage:
Confucius, as acting prime minister of Lu, had attended court for only seven days when he put Shaozheng Mao to death. His student came in and asked Confucius: "That Shaozheng Mao is a famous man of Lu. You take up the government and first of all kill him--surely there is no mistake?" Confucius said: "Sit down! I will tell you the reason. Man has five kinds of evil conduct, and theft is not included among them: one, a sharp mind put to sinister use; two, perverse conduct held to stubbornly; three, speech that is false yet winning; four, a record of ugly things, gathered broadly; five, following what is wrong and polishing it over. If a man has any one of these five kinds, he cannot escape the killing hand of the gentleman--and Shaozheng Mao had all five at once. Where he settled, he could gather a whole crowd of followers; his talk was enough to gloss over evil and beguile the masses; his force was enough to oppose what is right and stand alone. This is a formidable figure among petty men, and he had to be killed."
By Confucius's standard, who knows how many men in history would have lost their heads. I reckon that even Lord Mengchang, so courteous to worthy men, could be stretched onto that plane. And where, then, is the ren the sage Confucius preached? We have no wish here to run down the ancients; only, judging by this mode of killing of his, had he held office, killing by the bundle might have been the norm. To demand of ordinary men by the sage's standard, to mark whoever falls short of the standard as a petty man, and then kill at will--killing that needs no evidence, no judicial process--what kind of heavenly principle is that? This sage with a mouth full of humaneness and righteousness makes one shiver to think of it.
Yet the practical side of Confucian learning is also something the world cannot resist. "He who excels in learning shall serve in office" was always the highest guide to action for study in the ancient world. And rightly so:
"The Use of the Confucian"
In study seek the highest passing grade; in office seek a shining name;
gain rank and you are noble and honored--a nobility past all telling.
Since Confucian doctrine was the official orthodoxy of the patriarchal-clan society, Confucius was glorified beyond all reason, and no one might say one word against him, on pain of becoming a public enemy. Take the late-Ming thinker Li Zhi: at twelve he already heartily rejected Confucius's classifying the men who till the fields as "small men," and began writing essays to mock Confucius. All his life, for attacking the ruling thought of his day--Confucian learning--he was relentlessly suppressed; his teachings were branded "heresy" and "pernicious doctrine," his thought was held to "boldly preach ways of chaos, deluding the age and deceiving the people." Arrested and thrown into prison in his old age, unable to bear the disgrace, he snatched the barber's razor from the barber's hands, cut his own throat, and entered history in tragic grandeur.
And not only Li Zhi; many thinkers in history were the same. Read their works closely and it is a spiritual elevation--which makes the false and shallow sheen of certain words from the court seem all the more so. And rightly:
From of old, humaneness, righteousness, fame, and profit have weighed heavy--and it is the Confucians who have covered for them most.
To borrow political power to strike at the other schools of thought, to twist them, even to demonize them, was the Confucians' greatest crime in the history of Chinese thought, and the mark of the Confucians' lack of self-confidence.
As the ruler's official doctrine of choice, it had the duty, and the breadth of mind, to maintain a diversity of schools of thought.
In the end, this nation's history of philosophy and its treasury of thought need to be collated, publicized, and spread to the people with more objectivity, more fairness, more patient devotion--and with no political aim in the guiding.
Yet this Confucian keeping of the people in the dark is still being played out today.
A unified realm is a good thing; but the compulsory unification of thought is a nation's sorrow.
The Chinese generally hold that the greatest periods in Chinese history must be the Han and the Tang. The core reason is that those two dynasties were unified and their national power strong. But in fact, behind that strength, the status of Daoist thought as the state creed was crucial. It was the "governing by non-action" of the early Han that produced the "Rule of Wen and Jing," laying a solid foundation for the strength of the Han. Under Emperor Wu of Han the empire cut a mighty figure on every side, but that was where its national power began to weaken. Especially after Dong Zhongshu's "dismiss the hundred schools, honor Confucianism alone," it went downhill from there. A country, like a person, first slides in thought, and then declines in fate. Even the edict of self-blame that Emperor Wu issued in his later years could not retrieve the failing fortunes of the state. In the Tang it goes without saying: the House of Li flatly recognized Laozi as their ancestor and made Daoism the state religion--and then the strength of the Tang was such that none in the world could match it. Later, to serve the needs of her rule, Wu Zetian vigorously propped up Buddhism, and Daoism and Buddhism became the mainstream, while Confucianism slowly sank into a third-rate doctrine. This provoked the fight-to-the-death resistance of the intellectuals led by Han Yu. Since Daoism was the orthodox state religion, and a native religion at that, Han Yu took aim at Buddhism, the foreign religion, and attacked it fiercely, with the "Memorial Against Welcoming the Buddha's Bone" as the landmark event, launching a cultural movement to save Confucian learning.
(N lines omitted here)
But if one studies it from the side of philosophy and thought, I feel that China's richest and fullest periods were precisely the periods of national division, when warlords carved the land and contended for mastery--especially the Spring and Autumn and Warring States, and the Republican era--actually the Wei, the Jin, and the Northern and Southern Dynasties as well. In the ages when warlords carved up the land, the intellectuals belonged to no single political power's exclusive control, so thought and spirit were fairly free, and only then came the true "hundred flowers blooming, hundred schools contending" of the history of Chinese thought. Ah, let me not go on about this. It is too long a story.
Now then: since this nation has so many treasures of thought, why do so many people today barely know them?
The reason is the lack of guidance. In matters of the mind, this nation never seems to like going out to forage for itself; it is used to having someone feed it its spiritual food.
When I was studying in France, I once talked with a European professor about the traits of the various nations. He asked about the traits of us Chinese, and I said many proud things--and also expressed, tactfully, that ours is a domesticated nation, because saying so seemed to explain why the West had beaten us until we had no fight left, and made us look rather more civilized, rather better bred. Today I am writing in China, among our own people, doors closed for the talking. Some words I would rather not say, but I must admit: servility is one of the great traits of this nation. Especially after the Manchus came through the pass, what was sheared off the intellectuals was the hair on their heads; what was castrated was their thinking. High-level intellectuals thinking on their knees is a sight that goes far back; many a television drama has replayed the scene: every day at work, no matter how weighty the matter, all must wait until the three kneelings and nine prostrations are done and the mountain-shout of long life is finished before reporting on the day's work. And now and then the emperor would graciously grant one sentence: "Rise and make your report"--
Those of us who grew up in this era heard one sentence again and again in our growing up--"the Chinese people have stood up." I have never quite understood this sentence. Tell me, please: when did we ever fall down? Only a paralytic is that sensitive to the phrase "stand up." In truth, a country beaten to pieces is not the terrible thing; the real sorrow is the fall of thought, the enslavement of the spirit. Take one stretch of the last century: what made people's blood boil the most? The War of Resistance against Japan! For fighting the Japanese devils, the whole nation, top to bottom--that stirred the soul even more than toppling the Manchu Qing. And yet our historical films and literary subjects dwell mostly on the war with Japan: front line or enemy's rear, the battlefield beaten to flying flesh and blood, refusing with all their might to become the slaves of a fallen nation. The sentence "the rise or fall of the nation is every common man's duty" stirred the hot blood of the young of that day no less than the May Fourth era. Gu Yanwu, the late-Ming thinker who said it, lay long buried in the dust of history, yet his thought shone out brilliantly a little more than two hundred years after his death, and in toppling the Manchu Qing and in the War of Resistance this nation began to see how much thought matters to a nation's survival. But in recent years the scripts and literary works that reflect the War of Resistance are simply too many; some screenwriters, history-poor and word-starved, sink to inventing anything at all, and the distortion and absurdity of some anti-Japanese miracle dramas as history far outstrip the myth-novels. What money such writers and production crews make is none of our business; I only want to ask one thing: an audience misled like this--especially the children who have not yet touched the study of history--is your conscience at ease?
What I really want to say is this: besides the war, we still need a much heavier stroke in the recording and the publicizing of the realm of thought--that is, this nation's struggle in thought, its persistence in culture. The Republican government of the day resolved to preserve the nation's cultural bloodstream at any cost: it moved the three great universities--Tsinghua, Peking University, and Nankai--south together, and moved them again and again. The War of Resistance broke out in July 1937; the associated university began its move to Changsha that November, and moved on to Kunming in February 1938. The upheaval and hardship can be imagined. So on the anti-Japanese front it was not only a war of bullets and bodies; it was also a struggle of culture and spirit. Those intellectuals who taught and researched diligently through the war years for the continuation of the nation's cultural bloodstream were as great as any battle hero. There are many moving examples. To name one: the philosopher Jin Yuelin, during the Japanese air raids, ran up the mountain clutching his manuscript of seven hundred thousand characters, pressed it under his backside, and when the raid was over got up and went back to the university. Later, when he remembered it, the manuscript was gone. That truly shook the heart. (N lines omitted here)
(The picture above shows Gushi Bian, written by Mr. Gu Jiegang, the most true-hearted scholar of the Republican era)
The intellectuals of that period had backbone and minds of their own. The essence of Mr. Chen Yinke's thought can sum up that age roughly:
Independent spirit! Free thought!
-- (N lines omitted here)
For a time Marxism-Leninism was red-hot: the whole nation was studying Marx and Lenin, and the elites proudly proclaimed themselves steadfast Bolsheviks, forever keeping their advancedness. By contrast, toward this nation's own philosophy they were strangers--as toward a poor relation of their own: not wanting to acknowledge it, ashamed to speak of it, and knowing very little of it.
The start of interest in the national culture still could not do without the guidance of political figures. In recent years someone dredged up a sentence of Mao Zedong's--"of the men of recent times, I admire only Zeng Wenzheng"--and what do you know: the whole nation, paper dear as in Luoyang, and Zeng Guofan's books blazing beyond all bounds. Most of the people reading those books were not doing it for historical research or for cultural refinement, but to chase a fashion, or for some thought in the heart that could not be spoken aloud. That is forgivable enough; still, the greater part of the essence of China's history of philosophy and of thought remains far beyond the public's knowing.
I have noticed a phenomenon: in Western culture, those brilliant masters of philosophy are gazed up at and pursued in their own nations like the stars in the sky; whereas in the cultural notions of our society today, those masters of philosophy lie like sand and pebbles on the sea floor, quietly sunk to the bottom, unknown. The masses know the representative figures of their own national spirit less well than the gossip about some third-rank stars--so far that there could be the absurd affair of a film actor pushed up as the symbol of the national spirit.
Off on a tangent again. Too far off. Heh.
-- (N lines omitted here)
In the same chapter of the Xunzi, "Youzuo," is recorded another case of Confucius exercising judicial power at will; for reasons of space I shall not quote it.
So at times I actually find the words of the Western God more honest:
"Do not watch what I do; watch what I say!"
Now that is an honest saying, for talking is easy, and doing is truly hard. Preaching humaneness and virtue while practicing no righteousness may also be the way of rulers. Emperor Taizong of Tang, Li Shimin--so diligent in government, so loving of the people--was he not also the man who cut down his own two full brothers with his own hand? Yet that did not keep him from being a great ruler. Killing kin is killing kin, ruthlessness is ruthlessness, but the man did his main business, the governing of the state, as none before or since. That is the common verdict.
To speak from the heart: I very much dislike people with a mouth full of humaneness, righteousness, and virtue. Judging from many cases in Chinese history, such people are either guardians of the old faith or hypocrites. This kind of person starts by seizing the moral high ground with a ready-made theory, and then can move as he pleases--clouds with a flip of the hand, rain with the other--nothing he cannot do. Such people are a great nuisance, and ordinary folk can do nothing about them.
The harm a true villain does to society is far smaller than that of the hypocrite. Hypocrites often mimic the saint and appear in society, in the organs of power, practicing "loving the people" in name while "harming the people" in fact; hypocrites also mimic the "kind benefactor" and appear in our lives, acting "for your own good" in name while "trampling you" in fact. Such false friends are more frightening than enemies, and more deadly (for details see the essay "False Friends Are More Fearsome Than Tigers" in this official account).
Mention the hypocrite and I get worked up easily. It spoils my immortal-cultivating state of mind, ha ha. Enough; I will stop writing.
The essay is too long to finish at one sitting;
the author fears no toil--only that the reader will complain.
Heh.
A happy holiday! Appended are two diary jottings casually dashed off, for you who like old-style verse:
"Illness"
Pain upon pain, alas for me, lying ill in my study;
in the mirror my color is dark; outside the window, clouds and rain run wild.
In a blur my father and mother come; in a half-dream, old friends arrive;
sweet dew suddenly clears the spirit: Guanyin steps down from the lotus throne.
The tear-tracks on the brush have dried; paper and inkstone lie deep in dust;
long illness wears out the months and years; yet rosy clouds once more fill my heart.
At last the belt hangs loose on me--a fine and graceful figure;
this body bears its deep disease; this heart is all the more brilliant.
YZ.2019.3.12
Being sick is no fun at all. It hurt like death, hurt like death. Hurt till I fainted, till my head went muddy. In the half-dream, family and friends were all before my eyes, and even the gods and bodhisattvas of every quarter came. I suddenly understood a little why the old folks believed in the reliability of "crossing over to the shades." When I came back to my senses, it turned out not to be so. Which shows I am still some distance from being an immortal--still some distance.
"The Moon Rises Beyond the Eastern Sea"
The moon rises beyond the eastern sea; the sun sets behind the western hills;
between the strings, the sorrow of parting; beneath the brush, the sadness of spring.
Think of that cultivator of the Way, who half his life has sought the Dao;
not for any private self of his own, but to plan for all living beings.