The True Flavor of Human Life Is Plain Joy----Idle-Talk Notes (11)
11. The True Flavor of Human Life Is Plain Joy----Idle-Talk Notes (11)
Originally published by Yang Zi, Daozang Research, 2023-09-18
Listening to rain in the empty mountains, keeping warm around the stove on a snowy night, strolling beneath the moon, a light breeze stirring the skirt. Memories that move the heart in this life. YZ.2019.2.23
The Heart of a Pillar-Beam
If a tree could express itself, I believe it would surely be unwilling to become a beam, for that would mean paying the price of its life. YZ. 2011.3.16, night
In last week's selection of notes I wrote about "the blindfolded donkey," and a friend said I had written something profound (friends, of course, are encouraging me to write; they also know my temperament—I love to hear pleasant things, and whoever says something unpleasant, I simply stop talking to them. Ha ha). I did not know whether to laugh or cry. When I wrote it, what profound idea did I have? I had merely jotted down, offhand, a friend's account: of that top leader who once held great power in his hands, whose single word carried the weight of nine tripods, yet who after retirement became the target of humiliation in his own work unit—especially at the hands of subordinates he himself had promoted, whose conduct chills the heart and knows no shame. There is another view, that this humiliation is in some measure self-inflicted: why go back at all? The deed done, brush off your clothes and go, with no thought for past affections. Would that not be better? That way his former subordinates would not be put in a hard position, the new man taking over would have the space of authority he deserves, and he himself would keep his professional dignity, backbone, and face—far better than sitting there day after day, an eyesore and a hindrance, courting his own humiliation.
But without having lived through another's experiences, one has no standing to judge. In life, each person has that person's own hardships.
The handover of power is, in essence, the transfer of the realm. Once it is handed over, you can only be the fish while others are the knife and the chopping board. If you do not want to be chopped, the best way is to move away from the center of power, or to switch into some other space. Never mind a realm held in common for all—even in the age of the family-owned empire, it was so. The clever make their preparations early.
By chance, searching on the same topic, I also turned up a note from more than ten years ago:
Taking the stage is an accident; stepping down from the stage is a certainty. While you are on it, do not just busy yourself performing—remember that no matter how capable you are, you are sewing wedding clothes for someone else. And usually, not until the very end do you learn for whom you have been sewing them. So keep yourself prepared at all times; remember to have a step and a ladder ready for your own coming down. This goes especially for those who rise in one bound to the blue clouds—otherwise you may find yourself playing at free fall at any moment. The higher the post, the harder the fall. The greater the authority, the more wretched the tumble. YZ.2010.12.1
King Wuling of Zhao (Zhao Yong), in the prime of his life, gave the throne to his son Zhao He to inherit ahead of time. His thought was that with his son taking the throne early, he himself, still in his prime, could give the boy good support and temper him into a heroic sovereign, forging a powerful state. Who could have known that once power changed hands, loyal ministers would no longer be loyal ministers, and a filial son would no longer be a filial son? The ministers were no longer the ministers of before, and the son was no longer the son of before—everything had changed its face. His regret came too late to be of use, and in the end it was his son who shut him up inside the Shaqiu Palace (today's Xingtai, Hebei), and, alive as he was, starved him to death.
In the house of emperors there are no fathers and sons; it has been so since antiquity. One who has lost power and position is nothing at all. That is why so many emperors reigned until death before passing the throne on. As the saying current among people goes, "No place is more heartless than the house of an emperor." True indeed.
Being attached to power can be understood. Those who have never tasted the flavor of power can hardly understand it. Power is a thing more addictive than any drug. Whoever can let go of power as easily as letting out a fart—that is a great state of being, a great wisdom.
Speaking of dying at Shaqiu, it suddenly occurs to me that the First Emperor of Qin also died at Shaqiu, and there too it was sons fighting over the throne and shedding blood. Enough of that. YZ.2019.5.29
I have always loved Zheng Banqiao's writing. With some idle time on my hands, I will excerpt two pieces to savor:
1. Inscription on a Painting---Zheng Banqiao
Drunk today, well fed tomorrow; they say my state of affairs is quite upside-down. Little do they know that within my belly there is nothing but drafts of paintings. I paint one and give it to the prefect, and the prefect, all in a flurry, comes beating his gong. The onlookers all around marvel greatly, saying once more how fine the painted scroll is done. Pray ask the people of this world about the feelings herein: in a single word, how many turnabouts are there? Alas—in a single day, how many turnabouts are there?
Note: Interesting! Great fun! The turnabouts of worldly affairs, the turnabouts of human feeling, the inconstancy of the human heart, the inversion of right and wrong—who could ever sort them out? The Xianwen says:
Mountain stream water rises and ebbs with ease; the petty man's heart turns and turns again with ease.
Today, let me too idly pour out a doggerel verse for fun:
"The Song of Impermanence"
Bad today, good tomorrow; right and wrong, good and bad, without end.
Since of old, fine scenes have never long remained; since of old, fine things have never been stout.
In spring days the bright flowers blaze fresh; in a blink they have become autumn grass.
Morning and evening, once power is in your grasp, everyone shows you a pleasing face.
With power you can be the flower of ten thousand years; with power you can be the deathless grass.
Reading no scriptures, refining no elixir, the prefect has outdone the immortals.
Often we see the green hills green year after year; we never see true feeling stay lovely for long.
Do not laugh, sir, do not laugh.
Do not laugh that the prefect should be lonely; the prefect has fragrant grass every year.
The cold cicada never sees the winter scene; whose house of wealth and rank can long be kept?
No money, no power, no troubles—yet the lovely wife has gone off with another man.
Human feeling in this world turns and turns; in a single day, how many turnabouts?
Unmoved by favor or disgrace, you alone—simply because the mountain is high and the moon looks small.
2. Chanting a Poem on a Crab---Zheng Banqiao
Eight claws stalking sideways, the four wilds startle; twin pincers brandishing, the swagger overflows.
Who would know that within its belly it is empty of everything—dipped in ginger and vinegar, to be chanted over between cups of wine.
Note: It paints a picture!
Laughable, lamentable, hateful, pitiable!
Vents the temper, satisfies the craving, clears the puzzle, chases off the weariness!
The Remonstrator Dongfang Shuo
On remonstrating with rulers, history has produced much talent. In an earlier piece I once told the story of Jian Yong remonstrating with Liu Bei—very funny. Today, another master of remonstrance: Dongfang Shuo.
Dong Zhongshu wanted to dismiss the hundred schools and honor the Confucian arts alone. Emperor Wu of Han asked Dongfang Shuo for his thoughts; Dongfang Shuo said, first let us rest, drink tea, and listen to music.
The band arrived—only the drummer, beating "dong dong dong" on the drum, with not another soul in sight. The emperor was puzzled, and asked where all the flute-players and sheng-players had gone.
The answer came: They have all been dismissed.
And so Emperor Wu of Han understood.
Note: Understood he may have—yet he went on doing just what he had meant to do.
A famous couplet by Weng Tonghe:
Where writing is true, temperament shows; when laughter runs deep, wind and rain come.
Note: Full of flavor!
In company, leaning on no one; standing alone, unafraid---Su Shi
Note: I love this line of Su Dongpo's.
Any living creature that tries to stop a maddened bull from charging toward the cliff is trampled to death by the iron hooves in the very first instant. YZ.2023.9.9
Note: I dare not annotate.
The Craft of International Espionage
The cases of using spies that Sun Wu recorded in the Sunzi Bingfa (the "Yongjian" chapter, On the Use of Spies) are worth excerpting.
Of old, when Yin rose to power, Yi Zhi was in Xia; when Zhou rose to power, Lü Ya was in Yin. Hence only the enlightened ruler and the worthy general, able to use men of the highest wisdom as spies, will surely achieve great deeds. This is the crux of warfare: it is that on which the whole army depends for its every move. (Sun Wu, Sunzi Bingfa, "Yongjian" chapter)
The general meaning: In former times, the reason Yin-Shang rose was that Yi Yin served as a spy in Xia. When the Zhou dynasty was rising, Jiang Ziya gathered intelligence in Yin. Therefore, among enlightened rulers and worthy generals, those able to employ men of great cunning as spies will surely accomplish great deeds. Spies and intelligence are the key to military success and the basis on which armies act.
Today, let me first speak briefly of Yi Yin's work as a spy. Yi Yin counts as one of the earliest successful international spies in Chinese history. And his way of espionage was the most masterly of all.
First, word was spread that Tang of Shang and Yi Yin were at odds—public rumor, deliberately made. (This was a move to shape the overall political atmosphere: from the very start it was no maneuver at the level of technique. This point alone was enough to lay the foundation of success.
Then Yi Yin, bearing an arrow wound, used the self-injury ruse to enter Xia and take office, buying people over everywhere—even Moxi, wife of Jie of Xia. Jie of Xia had begun to lavish his favor exclusively on two newly presented beauties; Moxi, utterly cast aside, was in the very hour of her heartbreak. At just this time Yi Yin came and laid out his plan to her, and so:
Moxi, through her dealings with Yi Yin, thereby spied against Xia (Zhushu Jinian, the Bamboo Annals)
With Moxi cooperating with Yi Yin, the fate of the Xia dynasty began to change.
In the end, Moxi was successfully used by Yi Yin; Yi Yin became the hero, while Moxi went down as the number-one woman-made-disaster in the Lienü Zhuan.
Note one: Both were spies, yet one became a god and the other a ghost. That is not the difference between man and woman; it is the difference in calculation.
Note two: I feel truly sorry for Cao Cao of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Mind you, Cao Cao was the very man who wrote a commentary on the Sunzi Bingfa; mastery of the military art was one of his great advantages—and how strikingly alike were Huang Gai's self-injury ruse and Yi Yin's self-injury ruse! With Cao Cao's cleverness and wisdom, he could not have failed to see through a self-injury ruse—so why did he fall for it all the same? The key is that he too "employed spies in Wu": it was not Huang Gai he believed, but the intelligence his own spies in Eastern Wu brought back to him—and that intelligence happened to tally with Cao Cao's own conjectures, and to explain away, all too reasonably, every suspicious point in the case.
If one had operated according to the Sunzi Bingfa, the war was bound to be a great success. Then why did it fail? Is it that our divine book, the Sunzi Bingfa, does not work? Not so.
The reason is that in Cao Cao's use of spies in Eastern Wu there was one point that failed to meet the operating requirements of the military classic—namely, Sun Wu's original text says "those able to use men of the highest wisdom as spies will surely achieve great deeds." The requirement for a spy is a man of "highest wisdom," someone of truly great intelligence; only then can the intelligence he gathers be reliable. The key to the failure of Cao Cao's operation was that the men he used were simply too far beneath Zhou Yu in intelligence. And what wisdom Zhou Yu had—he might fairly be called "highest of the highest wisdom." The gap in intelligence was the root of it. This of course is not to compare Cao Cao with Zhou Yu as individuals, but a contest of intelligence between two entire spy networks. To be sure, the historical Cao Cao's defeat at Red Cliffs had many other complicated causes—plague, overconfidence bred by constant victory, and the like—but enough of that.
Living in Harmony with Ghosts
At the mention of Ji Xiaolan, how many people think at once of the humorous, many-talented figure of the television serial? The better-read will instantly recall the two great cultural projects of his life: the Siku Quanshu, which he directed as chief compiler, and the collection of tales of the strange, the Yuewei Caotang Biji.
However talented he was, thinkers and historians have judged him severely. The reason: as an elite Han scholar, in order to cater to the ruling needs of his Manchu masters, he carried out massive cutting of the broad corpus of ancient Chinese books—in truth he took up Dong Zhongshu's old post: the dismissal of the hundred schools, applied to books. Lu Xun, Tang Tao, and others once pronounced it "a consummate work in the castration of Chinese culture." And so Ji Xiaolan himself came to be called "a eunuch of the spirit." Hence, for all his ten thousand talents, he could not produce a single work of value in thought.
The academic worlds of Taiwan and Hong Kong have roundly criticized the Siku Quanshu as "Siku Bu Quanshu," the Four Treasuries that are not complete. One imagines Ji Xiaolan underground, covering his face with nowhere to hide. For any scholar with a conscience and a backbone would sooner lose his head than do such a thing. So the intellectuals of later generations mostly granted him his talent, but no one praised him for wisdom, still less looked up to his breadth of spirit or admired his integrity.
For a person who knows a few characters, to be worthy of the conscience within one's own awareness and understanding is already to have done one's utmost. After all, individuals differ. Many people of great talent have done short-sighted things that worked harm upon a nation's civilization, mostly because, given the age they lived in and the level of the knowledge they received, they never realized or foresaw that the long river of human history has all along been flowing onward. They merely did their duty within the pond of their own moment.
To the frog, the pond is all that is under heaven. To the autumn cicada, the summer day is eternity.
As for the style of the Yuewei Caotang Biji, he was plainly influenced by Pu Songling's Liaozhai Zhiyi. Be that as it may, the prose of that book is graceful, and it makes for entertaining reading; I sometimes take it up for pastime. For example:
The original text:
"Not Afraid of Ghosts" / As told by Cao Zhuxu of the Court of Agriculture
Cao Zhuxu of the Court of Agriculture told of a clansman of his who was traveling from She to Yangzhou and stopped on the way at a friend's house. It was the height of summer; he was invited to sit in the study, which was airy and cool, and at dusk he wished to lodge there. The friend said: "There is a haunting here; it cannot be lived in at night." Cao insisted on staying. At midnight something came wriggling in through the crack of the door, thin as a sheet of folded paper. Once inside the room it gradually spread open into the shape of a human being—a woman. Cao was not in the least afraid. Suddenly she let down her hair and thrust out her tongue, in the guise of a hanged ghost. Cao laughed and said: "It is still hair, only somewhat tangled; it is still a tongue, only somewhat longer—what is there to fear?" Suddenly she plucked off her own head and set it on the desk. Cao laughed again and said: "With a head you were not worth fearing; still less without one." The ghost's tricks were exhausted, and in a flash she was gone. On his return journey he lodged there again; at midnight something wriggled once more in the crack of the door, but the moment it showed its head, it spat out: "That spoilsport again, is it?" And it never came in. (Ji Yun of the Qing, Yuewei Caotang Biji)
The general meaning:
Cao Zhuxu of the Court of Agriculture said: A clansman of his was going from She county to Yangzhou and passed a friend's house on the way. It was the height of summer; the man broke off his journey and sat in his friend's study, finding the room thoroughly pleasant and cool. When dusk fell he wished to spend the night there, but the friend said: "There is a ghost here; you cannot stay the night in it." The man paid no heed and insisted on staying. Deep in the night, something came slowly in through the crack of the door, thin as a piece of folded paper. Once in the room, it gradually unfolded and took the shape of a human being—it was a woman. Cousin Cao was not afraid at all. The woman suddenly let down her hair, thrust out a long tongue, and took on the look of a hanged ghost. Cao laughed and said: "It is the same hair, only somewhat disheveled; it is the same tongue, only a little longer—what is there to fear?" The ghost then suddenly plucked off its own head and set it on the table. Cao laughed again and said: "A thing with a head I do not fear; how much less a thing without one!" The ghost's repertoire was exhausted, and in an instant it vanished. When Cao came back from Yangzhou and stayed there again, deep in the night something wriggled once more in the crack of the door. The moment it poked out its head, Cao spat out his curses: "That ill-starred thing again, is it?" And the ghost, in the end, never came in.
Note: People and ghosts are really just playing at a game; whether one is a person or a ghost often hangs in impermanence too. Being a person, if you run into a ghost, you really ought to cooperate a little—be frightened, you know. A true spoilsport is no fun; the ghost's game can no longer be played.
What sort of life, then, is the more fun? It takes people of high emotional intelligence to smooth things over. The emotionally intelligent are those who not only know how to give a person a face-saving way out, but also know how to give a ghost a face-saving way out.
As usual, two Daoqing chants:
"The True Flavor of the Human World Is Plain Joy"
The jade terrace and the royal seat rise over the void mountains; we talk of emptiness and discourse on the Dao between cups of wine;
Beneath the window I play the qin as my heart pleases; beyond the window the wind-blown dust has nothing to do with me.
In the third month the light of the woods is carried off with the flowers; following the wind, following the water, all according to nature;
The mirror stand freshly wiped, no powder falls; the incense not yet burnt out, a trailing thread of smoke.
As the mood takes me I take up the brush to unfold the great Dao; in every line and every character there sit immortals;
The whole screen, the whole sheet, breathes the air of mist and rosy cloud; I have not failed these many years of the Daoqing chant.
Human life has from of old been a lonely thing; alone I went into the red dust, and alone I return;
At first it was to flee trouble that I sought to leave the crowd; by the time I became an immortal, I no longer thought of going back.
A few streaks of flying spring, rain beating on rain; layer upon layer of empty green, mountain folded upon mountain;
The sundry birds in the woods sing the flourishing age; I ask you, conscience, how can you be at ease?
Snow buries the face three feet deep; ice chills human feeling ten feet cold;
How many toiling roads in this life of mine: nine parts of hardship to one part of sweet.
Wading across the muddy river of fame and gain, flying out of the cage at the pass of human feeling;
I have tasted to the full the wine immortals seldom get, and roamed every mountain ordinary folk never reach.
The body hidden in deep mountains, the mountains lose its shadow; the heart set upon the great sea, the sea stands level with heaven;
Tasted finely, does the human world have any flavor? The true flavor of the human world is plain joy.
"The Dao of Emptiness"
I have the great Dao, which prizes the clear and the empty; above, it may be honored; below, it may bend;
Call it nothing—ah, yet it cannot be cast away; call it something—ah, yet it cannot be dwelt in.