中国古代的学术分类
19、中国古代的学术分类
杨子 道藏研究 2015-10-11 19:51

春秋战国时期,虽然是诸子思想的形成时期,但当时并没有“诸子百家”这一概念。对先秦众多学术进行归类命名则是后世的杰作。本节主要简介司马谈、刘歆、吕思勉、冯友兰四位先哲对先秦诸子百家的分类。由于他们所处的时期不同,所以在分类依据和观念上也不同。
序号 分类 司马谈 刘歆 吕思勉 冯友兰
1 阴阳家 ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔
2 儒家 ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔
3 墨家 ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔
4 名家 ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔
5 法家 ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔
6 道家 ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔
7 纵横家 ✔ ✔
8 杂家 ✔
9 农家 ✔ ✔
10 小说家 ✔
11 兵家 ✔
12 医家 ✔
第一个对先秦思想进行分类的是司马迁的父亲司马谈(?----公元前110年)(司马迁也真是的,作为史学大家,不追捧父祖,连自己父亲的生平也不重视,仅重学术,这就是道家修持和境界的博大吧。要是换了儒家,一定为上辈的功德大书特书,以彰于世,因为“光宗耀祖”本就是儒家的追求目标)。司马氏本是上古时期颛顼帝时期重黎的后裔,在周宣王时期丢了主官天地的官职,开始称为司马氏,并世代掌管周朝的历史。历史沉浮,到了楚汉时期,司马一族归了汉,后代司马谈当了太史公。继续先祖的事业,写史。司马谈师从天文家唐都学习天文地理,又跟易学家杨何学习《易》,从事黄帝、老子道家思想的研究,并深得要旨。他担心后世难以了解学术思想的宗旨,所以对各家思想进行分类,他写了《论六家要旨》,把先秦思想分为六大类(如表):阴阳家、儒家、墨家、名家、法家、道家。司马迁(前145年—前90年)该文录入《史记》的《太史公自序》,《论六家要旨》的分类如下:

易大传:“天下一致而百虑,同归而殊涂。”夫阴阳﹑儒﹑墨﹑名﹑法﹑道德,此务为治者也,直所从言之异路,有省不省耳。尝窃观阴阳之术,大祥而觽忌讳,使人拘而多所畏;然其序四时之大顺,不可失也。儒者博而寡要,劳而少功,是以其事难尽从;然其序君臣父子之礼,列夫妇长幼之别,不可易也。墨者俭而难遵,是以其事不可篃循;然其强本节用,不可废也。法家严而少恩;然其正君臣上下之分,不可改矣。名家使人俭而善失真;然其正名实,不可不察也。道家使人精神专一,动合无形,赡足万物。其为术也,因阴阳之大顺,采儒墨之善,撮名法之要,与时迁移,应物变化,立俗施事,无所不宜,指约而易操,事少而功多。儒者则不然。以为人主天下之仪表也,主倡而臣和,主先而臣随。如此则主劳而臣逸。至于大道之要,去健羡,绌聪明,释此而任术。夫神大用则竭,形大劳则敝。形神骚动,欲与天地长久,非所闻也。(《史记—太史公自序第七十》)

该段内容是司马谈对六家的分类标准,同时也评点各学派思想的缺点,同时也指出各家思想的优势和可不缺少的原因。为方便理解,我将司马谈的诸子分类观点整理如下表:
司马谈对诸子的分类与评价
序号 类别 不足 优势
1 阴阳家 方术,夸大灾祥,忌讳众多,使人拘束而多畏惧 论四时大顺,不可缺少
2 儒家 广博而缺纲要,烦劳而少功效,难以全部信从 君臣父子、夫妇长幼之别,不可缺少
3 墨家 俭啬难以遵循 节俭,很务实
4 名家 使人拘束,丧失真实 确定名实关系,很必要
5 法家 严酷少恩寡情 可保持上下秩序,很必要
6 道(德)家 使人精神专一,行动符合自然规律。博采众长。
从此表对照可以清晰地看出,司马谈对各家思想都指出了不足,唯独对道家找不到缺点。不仅如此,他还认为道家灵活顺应事物变化,事情虽少但功效多,对道家极加推崇。他甚至拿儒家来对比论证,认为儒家把君主推为天下的表率,倡导臣下附和,君主在先而臣下在后,这样君主劳苦而臣下安逸。那样君主就会过于劳神过于疲倦,就会病倒,过于劳累同时还要想要万岁千秋,那是不可能的。所以他推崇大道的要点,去掉刚强和贪欲,君主少干涉臣下工作,自己任用道术御国。司马谈的这一思想后来成为中国历代君王“内圣外王”所奉行的经典,“内用黄老、外示儒术”一直是帝王的不二法门。
从司马谈的这一观点看,司马谈虽有史家的公正和客观,但也要推崇道家的主观。他的儿子司马迁也是道家思想,正是因为崇尚自然、追求自由的道家思想,才使得《史记》成为不朽的史书。由于司马谈和司马迁同为史学家并同时推崇道家思想的原因,再加上老子的职业背景等,后世刘歆在给诸子分类时,认为道家源于史家,这一点后面会有详细介绍。

第二个对诸子百家分类的人是刘歆(前50年—公元23年),西汉后期的古文经学家,属于校勘学、天文历法、史学、古诗等方面的全才,他编制了世界上最早的天文年历---《三统历谱》,他和司马迁一样,也是承袭父业的经典案例,在他父亲刘向编纂《别录》的基础上进一步整理,编成了中国第一部图书分类目录《七略》。在他的著作中,刘歆对诸子百家进行了分类,把诸子百家统筹分类为十家,在司马谈原分的六家的基础上,多出了纵横家、杂家、农家、小说家。
他的观点被班固(公元32—92年)记录如下:
儒家者流,盖出于司徒之官。道家者流,盖出于史官。阴阳家者流,盖出于羲和之官。法家者流,盖出于理官。名家者流,盖出于礼官。墨家者流,盖出于清庙之守。纵横家者流,盖出于行人之官。杂家者流,盖出于议官。农家者流,盖出于农稷之官。小说家者流,盖出于稗官。(《汉书—艺文志第十》)
除以上十家,刘歆还按工作性质和内容分类了兵家,他说:
“权谋者,以正守国,以奇用失,先计而后战,兼形势,包阴阳,用用技巧者也。---”
以及术数:
“天文者,序二十宿,步五星、日、月,以纪吉凶之象,圣王所以参政也---历谱者,序四时之位,正分至之节,会日、月、五星之辰,以考寒、暑、杀、生之实---五行者,五常之刑气也。---皆出于律历之数---蓍龟者,圣人之所用也。---杂占者,纪百事之象,候善恶之征---众占非一,而梦为大。---形法者,大举必州之执,以立城郭室舍形人及六畜骨法之度数,器物之形容以求其声气贵贱吉凶---数术者,皆明堂羲和史卜之职也。---”
又说方技:

“医经者,原人血脉、经络、骨髓、阴阳、表里,以起百病之本,死生之分,而用并箴石汤火所施,调百药齐和之所宜,至齐之得,犹慈石取铁,以物相使。---经方者,本草、石之寒、温,量疾病之浅、深,假药味之滋,因气感之宜,辩五苦六辛,致水火之齐,以通闭,解结,反之于平。---房中者,情性之极,至道之际,是以圣王制外乐及禁内情,而为之节文。---乐而有节,则各平寿考。---神仙者,所以人保性命之真,而游求于其外者也。---方技者,皆生生之具,王官之一守也。----
如此看来,刘歆把天文、历法、占卜、形法等都归为术数大类,把医学、医药学、性学、养生等归为方技,后来人们把方技和术数合统为方术,从事这些一职业的人为方士。以现代的学术分类看,这些才是真正的科学,但由于中国古代长期抑制方术的,妖魔化方术,认为从事这些职业的都上不务正业江湖骗子,除了中医学和中医药学因生命之必要而无法忽视之外,其他的学科都没有能得到应有的发展机遇,所有的发展只是一些道士在山中修行中进行各种化学、物理实验。但就是这样的环境,道家的一些道士还是做出了不少的研究成果,如《淮南子》的作者刘安在炼丹时发明了豆腐,《真元妙道要略》记载道士在炼丹时发明了火药等等,古代中国对科学研究做出重大贡献并付出代价的方士们,风餐露宿、用自己的身体做实验,不求名利却饱受儒学文化的欺凌,直到重视科技发展的今天,仍没有还方术一个公道的评价,很多文学作品还在妖魔化方术,这是有历史渊源的。从刘歆的分类中可以人看出,方术并不是出自什么官职,这也是中国技术发展得不到长足发展的深层次原因。

总体来看,刘歆对学术的分类标准与司马谈不同。司马谈是根据各家思想内容进行分类,而刘歆则是根据各家思想代表人物的出身和职业作为诸子各家的起源。这虽然算是一种学术创新,但也有些误导性,给人一种感觉只有当官的人才做学问,或是只有当官了做学问才可能成功,这也反应了中国古代学术唯贵族专有的事实。我个人同意冯友兰先生对刘歆这一分类的观点:“他对各家意义的阐述并不充分,有任意牵强之处”(冯友兰,《中国哲学简史》)。甚至怀疑刘歆是否真正的了解诸子各家学术的核心要领。比如他说名家源于礼官,他的理由是:“名位不同,礼亦异数,孔子曰:‘必也正名乎!名不正则言不顺,方不顺则事不成’,其所长也。”认为正名是名家的核心专长了。老实说,读到这段时,我忍不住笑了。我不相信这样一个大学问家会不知道名家以名实之辩为核心的,真难以想象名家代表人物惠施和公孙龙天上有知,会不会头撞天柱,大呼后世的无厘头。学问做到这个份上,也是一个笑话和娱乐。我一直在想,如果当时没有逻辑学这个词,用个“辩家”也是很合适的,司马谈当时忽略了,早知后世如此,不如当时好好思考给名家取个符合其真实学术思想的名字了。

在我所读过的史学家对先秦诸子百家的分类中,吕思勉算是理解得较为透彻的。他评价刘歆对学术的分类时说:
“杂家不能称家,小说家只是收辑材料,不能称学。术数一略,包括天文学和古代的宗教学,亦不能出于阴阳家以外。方技四家,实在只算一个医家。----所以我国古代的学术有:儒家(偏于伦理、政治方向)、道家(偏于哲学)、阴阳家(古代的宗教家言,包括天文 、律、历、算数等学)、法家(偏于政治、法律方面)、名家(近乎论理学)、墨家(也在伦理政治方面。而敬天明鬼,比起儒道两家来,宗教臭味略重)、纵横家(专家外交)、农家、兵家、医家。(吕思勉,《中国通史》)
吕思勉先生这一分类方法是与司马谈的方法相同的,按内容分。数量上与刘歆相同,共十大类。他对中国古代学术的总结是合适的,如果说我想改动一点点的话,就是对名家的注释可以为“偏于思辨、逻辑学”,其他的,都附合各家学术的主导思想及现代学科分类惯例。
虽然刘歆以学术的分类有不少问题,但他仍不失为一位令人尊敬的学问家。章太炎说:“孔子以后的最大人物是刘歆”,顾颉刚先生也称刘歆为“学术界的大伟人”。

受司马谈和刘歆的共同影响,冯友兰先生对诸子百家进行了自己的分类,在数量上他采用了司马谈的六家之说,分类依据上他借鉴了刘歆的职业之说,但根据不同的历史发展情况和个人知识背景,他对刘歆的分类进行了修正,冯友兰对诸子的分类如下 :
儒家者流,盖出于文士;墨家者流,盖出于游侠之士;道家者流,盖出于隐者;名家者流,盖出于辩者;阴阳家者流,盖出于方士;法家者流,盖出于法术之士。

这种分法有几分道理,是一种后验推理命名,不是真正的各家思想的渊源出处。我个人是不大认可的。不过也不太执着于这些争来争去的观点,“千江有水千江月”,只要有水的地方,都会有一个月亮在,但天上的月亮,永远只有一个。不多言。
The Classification of Learning in Ancient China
19. The Classification of Learning in Ancient China
By Yangzi, Daozang Yanjiu, 2015-10-11 19:51
The Spring and Autumn and Warring States period, though it was the era when the thought of the various masters took shape, had at the time no concept of the "hundred schools of the masters." To classify and name the many schools of pre-Qin learning was the work of later ages. This section briefly introduces the classifications of the pre-Qin hundred schools by four earlier thinkers: Sima Tan, Liu Xin, Lü Simian, and Feng Youlan. Because they lived in different periods, their grounds of classification and their views differ as well.
No. | School | Sima Tan | Liu Xin | Lü Simian | Feng Youlan
1 | The Yin-Yang school | ✔ | ✔ | ✔ | ✔
2 | The Confucians | ✔ | ✔ | ✔ | ✔
3 | The Mohists | ✔ | ✔ | ✔ | ✔
4 | The School of Names | ✔ | ✔ | ✔ | ✔
5 | The Legalists | ✔ | ✔ | ✔ | ✔
6 | The Daoists | ✔ | ✔ | ✔ | ✔
7 | The Diplomatists | ✔ | ✔
8 | The Eclectics | ✔
9 | The Agriculturists | ✔ | ✔
10 | The Minor-Talks school | ✔
11 | The Military school | ✔
12 | The Medical school | ✔
The first to classify pre-Qin thought was Sima Qian's father, Sima Tan (?--110 BC). (Really, that Sima Qian! A great master of history, yet he did not puff up his father and forebears--did not even attend to his own father's life, but only to the learning. That, I suppose, is the breadth of Daoist cultivation and its state of mind. Had it been a Confucian, he would surely have written at enormous length of the merits of the generation before, to display them to the world, for "bringing glory to one's ancestors" is precisely the Confucian's goal.) The Sima clan were descendants of Chongli of the age of Emperor Zhuanxu in high antiquity; in the reign of King Xuan of Zhou they lost their hereditary office in charge of heaven and earth, began to be called the Sima clan, and for generations kept the historical records of the Zhou court. Then history rose and fell; by the Chu-Han period the Sima clan had gone over to Han, and their descendant Sima Tan became the Grand Historian, continuing the work of his ancestors: writing history. Sima Tan studied astronomy and geography under the astronomer Tang Du, and the Yi under the Yi master Yang He, and devoted himself to the study of the Daoist thought of the Yellow Emperor and Laozi, grasping its essential import. Fearing that later ages would find it hard to grasp the essential aims of intellectual thought, he classified the thought of the various schools; he wrote the Lun Liujia Yaozhi, dividing pre-Qin thought into six great classes (as in the table): the Yin-Yang school, the Confucians, the Mohists, the School of Names, the Legalists, and the Daoists. Sima Qian (145 BC--90 BC) entered the text into the "Taishigong Zixu" of his Shiji. The classification of the Lun Liujia Yaozhi is as follows:
The Great Commentary of the Yi says: "In all under heaven the goal is one, yet the deliberations are a hundred; they arrive at the same place, yet by different roads." The arts of the yin-yang masters, the Confucians, the Mohists, the School of Names, the Legalists, and the Dao-de school are all alike devoted to the work of good government; they differ only in the roads by which they state it, and some are more skillful than others. I have privately observed the art of the yin-yang masters: it is full of grand auspices and crowded with taboos, leaving men constrained and fearful of much; yet its ordering of the great sequence of the four seasons cannot be lost. The Confucians are broad but short of essentials, laborious and small of result, so that their program is hard to follow entirely; yet their ordering of the rites of ruler and minister, father and son, and their arrangement of the distinctions of husband and wife, elder and younger, cannot be changed. The Mohists are frugal to the point of hardship, so their program cannot be wholly followed; yet their strengthening of the root and their restraint in spending cannot be abandoned. The Legalists are stern and scant of kindness; yet their rectification of the distinctions between ruler and minister, high and low, cannot be altered. The School of Names leaves men petty and prone to lose the true; yet its rectification of names and actualities must be examined. The Dao-de school makes men's spirits concentrated and one, their movements in accord with the formless, ample for the ten thousand things. As an art, it follows the great sequence of yin and yang, gathers the good of the Confucians and the Mohists, grasps the essentials of the School of Names and the Legalists, shifts with the seasons and changes with things, establishes customs and carries out affairs with nothing unsuited, its directions simple and easy to hold, its tasks few and its results many. The Confucians are otherwise. They hold that the lord of men is the model for all under heaven: the lord leads and the ministers harmonize, the lord goes first and the ministers follow. Then the lord is worn with toil while the ministers sit at ease. As for the essentials of the great Dao: cast away strength and craving, dim the keenness of eye and ear, let go of these and trust to the art. When the spirit is heavily used it is exhausted; when the body is heavily taxed it breaks down. With body and spirit both in tumult yet hoping to last as long as heaven and earth--that I have never heard of. (Shiji, "Taishigong Zixu," No. 70)
This passage gives Sima Tan's criteria for classifying the six schools, while at the same time pointing out the shortcomings of each school's thought and indicating each one's strengths and the reason it cannot be dispensed with. For ease of understanding, I have arranged Sima Tan's views on the classification of the masters into the following table:
Sima Tan's Classification and Evaluation of the Masters
No. | School | Shortcomings | Strengths
1 | The Yin-Yang school | Divinatory arts; magnify calamities and auspices; taboos numerous, leaving men constrained and fearful | Its ordering of the great sequence of the four seasons; indispensable
2 | The Confucians | Broad yet without essentials, laborious yet small of result, hard to follow entirely | The distinctions of ruler and minister, father and son, husband and wife, elder and younger; indispensable
3 | The Mohists | Frugality hard to follow | Frugality; very practical
4 | The School of Names | Leaves men constrained, losing the true | The fixing of the relation of names and actualities; very necessary
5 | The Legalists | Harsh, scant of kindness, poor in feeling | Preserves the order of high and low; very necessary
6 | The Dao (Dao-de) school | Makes men's spirits concentrated and one, their movements in accord with the laws of nature. Gathers the strengths of all.
Set side by side in this table one can see clearly: Sima Tan found shortcomings in every school's thought, yet in the Daoists alone he could find no fault. Not content with that, he held that the Daoist school flexibly follows the changes of things, that its tasks are few but its results many, and he esteemed the Daoists above all. He even argued it out by contrast with the Confucians: the Confucians set the ruler up as the model for all under heaven and urge the ministers to fall in with him, the ruler in front and the ministers behind, so the ruler toils and the ministers take their ease. Ruler worn out by excessive mental strain, prostrated by fatigue, sick unto falling; yet while toiling past endurance he still hopes for ten thousand years and a thousand autumns--that is impossible. Hence he esteemed the essentials of the great Dao: cast off hardness and craving, let the ruler meddle little in his ministers' work and govern the realm by the Daoist art. This thought of Sima Tan's later became the classic followed by China's emperors, age after age, in the manner of "sage within, king without"; "inwardly using the Huang-Lao, outwardly showing Confucian technique" was ever the unvarying method of the throne.
Seen from this view of Sima Tan's, he had the historian's fairness and objectivity, yet also a subjective esteem for the Daoist school. His son Sima Qian was of the Daoist persuasion as well; it was precisely that Daoist thought, honoring nature and pursuing freedom, that made the Shiji an immortal work of history. Because Sima Tan and Sima Qian were both historians and both esteemed the Daoist school, and given Laozi's own professional background and other such factors, the later Liu Xin, when classifying the masters, held that the Daoist school sprang from the historians. This point will be treated in detail later.
The second to classify the hundred schools of the masters was Liu Xin (50 BC--AD 23), an Old Text classicist of the late Western Han, a universal talent spanning textual criticism, astronomy and calendrics, history, and old poetry. He drew up the world's earliest astronomical annual calendar, the Santong Lipu. Like Sima Qian, he is a classic case of carrying on the father's trade: building on the Bielu compiled by his father Liu Xiang and carrying the work further, he produced the Qilüe, China's first classified catalog of books. In his works Liu Xin classified the hundred schools of the masters, grouping them into ten schools: on the basis of Sima Tan's original six, he added the Diplomatists, the Eclectics, the Agriculturists, and the Minor-Talks school.
His views were recorded by Ban Gu (AD 32--92) as follows:
The school of the Confucians, it seems, arose from the office of the Situ. The school of the Daoists, it seems, arose from the office of the historians. The school of the Yin-Yang masters, it seems, arose from the office of Xihe. The school of the Legalists, it seems, arose from the office of the judges. The school of the Names masters, it seems, arose from the office of the rites. The school of the Mohists, it seems, arose from the keepers of the Pure Temple. The school of the Diplomatists, it seems, arose from the office of the messengers. The school of the Eclectics, it seems, arose from the office of the counselors. The school of the Agriculturists, it seems, arose from the office of agriculture and millet. The school of Minor Talks, it seems, arose from the office of the minor officers. (Hanshu, "Yiwenzhi," No. 10)
Beyond these ten schools, Liu Xin also classified the Military school by the nature and content of the work. He said:
"Those of strategy and stratagem: they defend the state with the orthodox and employ the unexpected in war; they plan first and fight after; they combine situation and advantage, embrace yin and yang, and use the arts of technique...--"
And also the arts of the numbers (shushu):
"Those of celestial patterns: they order the twenty-eight lodgings, pace the five planets, the sun, and the moon, to record the signs of fortune and misfortune, by which the sage kings assisted their governance... Those of calendars and tables: they order the positions of the four seasons, rectify the nodes of the solstices and equinoxes, bring together the hours of sun, moon, and five planets, to examine the realities of cold, heat, death, and life... Those of the five phases: they are the configurations and qi of the five constants... All issue from the numbers of pitch-pipes and calendars... Those of milfoil and tortoise: what the sages used... Those of miscellaneous divination: they record the signs of the hundred affairs and watch for the omens of good and evil... The divinations are many, but dreams are the greatest... Those of forms and methods: they establish the measures of city walls and dwellings, the forms of men, and the bone-methods of the six livestock, the looks of vessels, to seek from their sound and breath the noble and the base, fortune and misfortune... The arts of the numbers: all are the offices of the Bright Hall, of Xihe, and of the historians of divination...--"
And he spoke of the medical arts (fangji):
"The medical canons: they trace the origins of man's blood vessels, meridians, marrow, yin and yang, exterior and interior, to identify the roots of illnesses and distinguish life from death; and they apply needles, medicinal stones, decoctions, and heat treatments, blending the hundred drugs to what is fitting--the finest prescription is like the lodestone drawing iron, one thing moving another... The canonical recipes: they taste the cold and warmth of herbs and stones, measure the shallowness and depth of illness, borrow the nourishment of the drug flavors, follow what suits the influence of qi, distinguish the five bitters and six acrids, bring water and fire to the prescription, to open blockages, undo knots, and return the body to balance... The arts of the bedchamber: the utmost of passion and nature, the border of the perfect Way; hence the sage kings made outer music and forbade inner passion, composing restraint for it... Where there is joy with restraint, each lives out his years in peace... The immortals: those who thereby preserve the true of man's nature and life, and roam in search of what lies beyond it... The medical arts: all are the tools of life-giving life, one of the charges of the royal offices...--
Seen thus, Liu Xin gathered astronomy, calendrics, divination, forms and methods, and the rest into the great class of the arts of the numbers, and medicine, pharmacology, the study of sex, and nourishing life into the medical arts. Later people joined the medical arts and the arts of the numbers together under the name of the technical arts (fangshu), and those who practiced these trades were called the masters of the arts (fangshi). By the classification of modern learning, these were the true science. But because ancient China long suppressed the technical arts, demonized the technical arts, and held that all who practiced these trades were idlers and mountebanks, apart from Chinese medicine and Chinese pharmacology, which the necessities of life made impossible to ignore, none of these disciplines ever got the chance at development they deserved. All the development there was, was some Daoist or other in his mountain retreat carrying out experiments in chemistry and physics. Yet even in such an environment, some of the Daoist priests still achieved a good deal of research: Liu An, author of the Huainanzi, invented tofu while refining the elixir; the Zhenyuan Miaodao Yaolüe records Daoists inventing gunpowder while refining the elixir, and so on. The masters of the arts of ancient China, who made great contributions to the research of science and paid dearly for it, sleeping in the wind and dew, experimenting on their own bodies, seeking neither fame nor gain yet suffering constant humiliation from the culture of Confucian learning--even today, when the development of science and technology is prized, the technical arts have still not been given a fair judgment, and much literature still demonizes them. This has deep historical roots. From Liu Xin's classification one can see that the technical arts did not spring from any official office--and this, too, is a deep-level reason why China's technical development could not make great strides.
On the whole, Liu Xin's criteria for classifying learning differed from Sima Tan's. Sima Tan classified by the content of each school's thought; Liu Xin took the origins and professions of each school's representative figures as the origins of the schools. Though this counts as an innovation in learning, it is also somewhat misleading, leaving the impression that only officials do scholarship, or that only after becoming an official can one succeed in scholarship--which mirrors the fact that ancient Chinese learning belonged to the nobility alone. I personally agree with Mr. Feng Youlan's view of Liu Xin's classification: "His accounts of the meaning of the various schools are not always adequate, and there are forced and arbitrary points" (Feng Youlan, "A Short History of Chinese Philosophy"). I even doubt whether Liu Xin truly grasped the essential core of each school's learning. For example, he said the School of Names arose from the office of the rites, his reason being: "Ranks differ, and the rites differ in number. Confucius said: 'It must begin with the rectification of names! If names are not rectified, speech does not go smoothly; if speech does not go smoothly, affairs do not succeed'--that is their strength." So he took the rectification of names to be the core specialty of the School of Names! To be honest, when I read that passage I could not help laughing. I refuse to believe that so great a scholar did not know that the School of Names is centered on the debate over names and actualities. I can hardly imagine what Hui Shi and Gongsun Long, the representative figures of that school, would do if they knew of it in heaven--dash their heads against the pillar of heaven and cry out at the senselessness of posterity. When learning reaches this pass, it turns into a joke and an entertainment. I have often thought: if at that time there had been no word for logic, "the school of disputation" would have been quite a fitting name; Sima Tan passed the point by then. Had he known what later ages would make of it, he would have done better to think it over carefully and give the School of Names a name that fit its true intellectual content.
Of the historians I have read who classified the pre-Qin hundred schools, Lü Simian understood them rather thoroughly. Evaluating Liu Xin's classification of learning, he said:
"The Eclectics cannot be called a school; the Minor-Talks school only gathers material and cannot be called learning. The one register of the arts of the numbers includes astronomy and the religion of antiquity, and cannot go outside the Yin-Yang school. The four schools of the medical arts really count as one Medical school... Thus the learning of ancient China comprises: the Confucians (inclined toward ethics and politics), the Daoists (inclined toward philosophy), the Yin-Yang school (the words of the ancient religionists, including astronomy, pitch-pipes, calendars, arithmetic, and such studies), the Legalists (inclined toward politics and law), the School of Names (close to logic), the Mohists (also in ethics and politics; but their reverence for Heaven and affirmation of the existence of spirits gives them a somewhat heavier religious flavor than the Confucians and the Daoists), the Diplomatists (specialists in diplomacy), the Agriculturists, the Military school, and the Medical school. (Lü Simian, Zhongguo Tongshi)
Mr. Lü Simian's method of classification is the same as Sima Tan's: by content. In number it is the same as Liu Xin's, ten great classes in all. His summary of ancient Chinese learning is fitting. If I were to change a little bit, it would be the note on the School of Names, which could read "inclined toward disputation and logic"; the rest all agree with each school's leading ideas and with the conventions of modern classification.
Though Liu Xin's classification of learning has no few problems, he remains a scholar to be respected. Zhang Taiyan said: "The greatest figure after Confucius is Liu Xin," and Mr. Gu Jiegang also called Liu Xin "a great man of the world of learning."
Under the joint influence of Sima Tan and Liu Xin, Mr. Feng Youlan made his own classification of the hundred schools. In number he adopted Sima Tan's six schools; in his grounds of classification he drew on Liu Xin's theory of professions; but according to the differing course of history and his own background of knowledge, he revised Liu Xin's classification. Feng Youlan's classification of the masters is as follows:
The school of the Confucians, it seems, arose from the men of letters; the school of the Mohists, it seems, arose from the wandering knights; the school of the Daoists, it seems, arose from the hermits; the school of the Names masters, it seems, arose from the disputers; the school of the Yin-Yang masters, it seems, arose from the masters of the arts; the school of the Legalists, it seems, arose from the men of law and statecraft.
This division has a certain sense to it. It is a naming by inference after the fact, not the true source of each school's thought. I personally do not much accept it. Still, I do not cling overmuch to these endlessly disputed views: "A thousand rivers hold a thousand moons." Wherever there is water, there is a moon in it; but the moon in the sky is, and always remains, one only. No more to be said.